


Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Community
Ask the community for help and clear up your study doubts
Discover the best universities in your country according to Docsity users
Free resources
Download our free guides on studying techniques, anxiety management strategies, and thesis advice from Docsity tutors
The differences between federal and state law in the United States, and what happens when federal law conflicts with state law, using marijuana as an example. It discusses the preemption doctrine and how states can have laws permitting the use of marijuana despite federal law. The document also explores the case of United States v. McIntosh and the Supreme Court's ruling on the Controlled Substances Act. informative and comprehensive, providing a detailed overview of the topic.
Typology: Essays (university)
1 / 4
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!
Explain the difference between federal and state law in as much detail as you can and then explain what happens when the federal law conflicts with state law such as with marijuana both recreational and medicinal. Explain how any state can have laws permitting the use of marijuana given the federal law and the preemption doctrine. Be as comprehensive as you can including whether someone using marijuana within a state under the state law can be prosecuted by the federal government. Issue Spotter 1 Federal law is the law of the United States of America and is made up of the Constitution, federal statutes, executive orders, regulations, and court decisions. These laws apply to the entire nation and are enforced by federal agencies such as the FBI, IRS, and the Department of Justice. They are created and enforced by the federal government and are supreme over any state laws that may conflict with them. State law is the law of an individual state within the United States, and is made up of the state constitution, state statutes, executive orders, regulations, and court decisions. These laws apply only to the state in question and are enforced by state agencies such as the state police and the state judiciary. They are created and enforced by the state government and are subordinate to federal law when the two conflict. Federal law is given precedence over state law in cases where they contradict. This means that while a state may have passed a law legalizing marijuana, either recreationally or medicinally, the federal law still prohibits the possession, manufacture, and distribution of marijuana. This means that even if state law allows the use of marijuana, federal law enforcement can still prosecute individuals for the possession, manufacture, and distribution of marijuana. According to State and Federal Powers Clash Over Medical Marijuana In United States V. McIntosh article, Alsterberg discussed the case of United States v. McIntosh, which was the
first case to consider the federal government’s authority to enforce the Controlled Substances Act (CSA) against individuals who possess marijuana for medical use in states that have legalized its use for this purpose. In this case, the Supreme Court sided with federal law, ruling that the CSA prohibits individuals from engaging in the distribution of marijuana, even if the activity is permitted under state law. The Supreme Court decided that the CSA prohibits states from legalizing the medicinal purposes of marijuana. This implies that, even if a state has approved legislation permitting the medical use of marijuana, federal law still takes precedence over state law, and the CSA is still implemented. The laws established by the federal government of a country are referred to as federal law. It is applicable throughout the country and supersedes state laws on the same subject matter. Federal law is usually made by the national parliament or Congress. State law, on the other hand, is the set of laws developed by a federal country's individual states. It is only enforceable inside the state and may differ from one state to the next. This is because the Constitution of the United States grants the federal government the power to create laws that are applicable throughout the country, and this power is known as federalism. Under the preemption doctrine, federal law is the supreme law of the land and any state law that conflicts with federal law is invalid (Waters 35). Despite this doctrine, states are still able to pass laws permitting the use of marijuana, as long as the state law does not conflict with federal law. For example, many states now have laws allowing for the medical use of marijuana such as Alaska, Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Colorado, etc. These state laws can coexist with federal law because the medical use of marijuana is not explicitly prohibited by the federal Controlled Substances Act. Therefore, state law is not in conflict with federal law and is not preempted. Similarly, some states have passed laws decriminalizing or even legalizing the
Works Cited Alsterberg, Cara E. “STATE AND FEDERAL POWERS CLASH OVER MEDICAL MARIJUANA IN UNITED STATES V. MCINTOSH.” Golden Gate University Law Review , vol. 47, no. 1, 2017, p. 89. “The Differences between Federal, State, and Local Laws.” LawHelp.org , https://www.lawhelp.org/resource/the-differences-between-federal-state-and-loc. Avery, Dan. “Which States Have Legalized Marijuana?” CNET , https://www.cnet.com/news/politics/marijuana-laws-by-state-where-is-weed-legal/. Waters, Luke C. "Does Federal Law Preempt State Marijuana Law?." COLORADO LAWYER (2018).