Download Introduction to Literary Theory and Criticism and more Study notes English Literature in PDF only on Docsity!
Unit 1: Greek and Roman Theory
Topic: Aristotle - Poetics (Translation by S. H. Butcher)
Introduction to Aristotle’s Poetics
Aristotle’s Poetics is one of the most significant texts in the history of Western literary criticism. It is a treatise on the theory of literature and drama, especially focusing on tragedy. Written in the 4th century BCE, Poetics provides detailed analysis and defines the essential elements of drama. The treatise was originally in Greek, and the most famous translation was by S. H. Butcher (1895), which has been widely studied for its clarity and accuracy.
Key Areas Covered in Poetics include:
● The nature and purpose of poetry and drama. ● The structure of tragedy. ● The role of characters and their development. ● The emotional impact of the tragedy on the audience (catharsis). ● The comparison between different genres of poetry (e.g., epic poetry and tragedy).
1. The Concept of Mimesis (Imitation)
Aristotle begins by discussing mimesis , the concept of imitation, which he believes is inherent in all forms of art. According to Aristotle:
● Mimesis is the act of imitating or representing real life, actions, and emotions through art. Humans are naturally drawn to mimic the world around them, which leads to learning and experiencing emotions. ● He believes all art, including tragedy , comedy , and epic poetry , is an imitation of human actions and emotions. ● The primary aim of drama, particularly tragedy, is to represent a serious action and evoke a sense of pity and fear in the audience.
2. The Purpose of Tragedy (Catharsis)
Aristotle’s concept of catharsis is one of the most important aspects of his theory of tragedy:
● Catharsis refers to the emotional purification or release that the audience experiences after watching the tragic events unfold. ● When the audience witnesses the suffering of the tragic hero, they experience pity (for the hero’s misfortune) and fear (of their own potential downfall). ● By experiencing these emotions, the audience undergoes a purification of these emotions, leading to emotional balance. This cathartic experience is essential for the moral and emotional impact of the tragedy.
Aristotle argues that tragedy is not only an imitation of life but a way to engage the audience in a deep emotional and moral experience.
3. The Six Elements of Tragedy (Major Concepts)
Aristotle identifies six key elements that are essential for creating a successful tragedy. These elements work together to evoke the desired emotional response and contribute to the coherence of the play.
1. Plot (Mythos): The Core of Tragedy
Aristotle believes that the plot is the most important element in a tragedy. The plot must have the following qualities:
● Unity of Action : The plot must be a unified whole, with every event connected logically to the next. Each event should be necessary and contribute to the overall story. ● Beginning, Middle, and End : A well-constructed plot should have a clear beginning, middle, and end. The events should unfold in a way that is natural and follows a cause and effect relationship. ● Peripeteia (Reversal of Fortune): A turning point in the plot where the protagonist’s situation changes from good to bad (or vice versa). This is a pivotal moment where the expectations of the audience are upended. ● Anagnorisis (Recognition): The moment of realization or self-awareness by the protagonist. This usually happens at the same time as the peripeteia and is crucial for the tragic hero's fall. ● Complexity : Aristotle values complex plots over simple ones. A complex plot includes reversal and recognition because these elements generate deeper emotional engagement.
2. Character (Ethos): The Tragic Hero
Characters are crucial in making the plot believable and engaging. A good tragic hero must:
● Be of noble birth or high status , so the audience cares about their downfall. ● Have a tragic flaw (hamartia) that leads to their downfall. This flaw is often a character trait like pride (hubris), poor judgment, or ambition.
● The plot and characters should remain the core elements of a good tragedy. Spectacle only enhances the overall experience.
4. The Role of the Tragic Hero and Hamartia
A tragic hero is central to the emotional impact of a tragedy. The hero must be:
● Noble in nature, typically from a high social status. ● Flawed (hamartia), with a tragic flaw that leads to their downfall. The flaw is often hubris (excessive pride), which leads the hero to make fatal errors. ● Recognizable : The audience should identify with the hero’s experiences, which makes their downfall even more poignant.
The tragic hero’s hamartia brings about their peripeteia (reversal of fortune), and the hero’s anagnorisis (recognition) of their flaw or mistake is a critical moment in the tragedy.
5. Aristotle’s Comparison of Epic Poetry and Tragedy
Aristotle also compares epic poetry with tragedy :
● Epic Poetry : Epic poems like Homer’s Iliad and Odyssey are lengthy narratives that cover a wide scope in terms of time and space. They involve multiple characters and a broad range of events. ● Tragedy : Tragedy, on the other hand, is a shorter, more focused narrative , typically occurring within a single day and at a single location. The tragedy focuses on one protagonist and the emotional consequences of their actions.
Aristotle prefers tragedy because it is more intense and concentrated, which makes it more emotionally effective.
6. Unity of Time, Place, and Action
While Aristotle does not insist on the strict unities that later critics would, he does suggest that a tragedy should observe the unity of action :
● Unity of Action : The plot must be cohesive, and all events should serve the central narrative. ● Unity of Time : Ideally, the events of a tragedy should unfold within a short time frame (often one day), which keeps the emotional tension high.
● Unity of Place : The action should take place in one location to maintain the focus of the audience.
7. Aristotle's Legacy in Literature and Drama
Aristotle’s work on tragedy had a profound influence on the development of Western theatre, literature, and criticism:
● Shakespeare and many other playwrights followed Aristotle’s principles of plot and character construction. ● Modern film also owes much to Aristotle’s theories of plot structure and emotional engagement. ● Literary criticism continues to use Aristotle’s framework to analyze characters, plot, and thematic depth.
Summary of Key Concepts:
● Mimesis : Imitation of life. ● Catharsis : Emotional release. ● Tragic Hero : A noble character with a tragic flaw. ● Hamartia : The tragic flaw that leads to the hero’s downfall. ● Plot : The core of tragedy, focusing on cause-and-effect structure. ● Peripeteia : Reversal of fortune. ● Anagnorisis : The hero’s realization of their mistake. ● Epic Poetry vs. Tragedy : Epic poetry is expansive, while tragedy is focused and emotional. ● Unity of Action, Time, and Place : The importance of a cohesive and compact narrative.
Key Terms to Remember:
● Mimesis – Imitation of life. ● Catharsis – Emotional cleansing. ● Hamartia – Tragic flaw. ● Peripeteia – Reversal of fortune. ● Anagnorisis – Recognition or realization.
- What does ‘Anagnorisis’ mean in a tragedy? Answer : Anagnorisis is the moment of recognition or realization when the protagonist understands their mistake or the truth about their situation.
- What is the role of ‘Diction’ in tragedy? Answer : Diction refers to the language used in the tragedy. It must be appropriate to the characters, the themes, and the emotional tone of the play.
- What is the difference between epic poetry and tragedy? Answer : Epic poetry is long and expansive, covering a wide range of events, while tragedy is focused, concise, and centered around a single plot and a few characters.
- What is the primary purpose of tragedy according to Aristotle? Answer : The primary purpose of tragedy is to evoke pity and fear , leading to the audience’s emotional catharsis.
- What is the importance of the ‘Chorus’ in Aristotle’s Poetics****? Answer : The chorus plays a significant role in enhancing the emotional atmosphere, providing commentary, and reflecting on the action and themes of the play.
- How does Aristotle describe the ideal length of a tragedy? Answer : Aristotle advocates that a tragedy should be long enough to allow the plot to unfold naturally and should be able to evoke pity and fear without being overly extended.
Short Answer Questions (3-4 Marks)
- Explain the concept of ‘Unity of Action’ in Aristotle’s theory of tragedy. Answer : Unity of Action suggests that a tragedy should have a single plot with a clear structure (beginning, middle, and end). Every event in the plot should be necessary to the progression of the story, contributing to the overall action.
- Discuss the role of the tragic hero in a tragedy according to Aristotle. Answer : The tragic hero is a central character, typically of noble birth, who possesses a tragic flaw (hamartia). The hero’s flaw leads to their downfall, which evokes pity and fear in the audience. The hero usually experiences anagnorisis and peripeteia.
- What are Aristotle’s views on the importance of ‘Plot’ in a tragedy? Answer : Aristotle considers plot the most important element of a tragedy. The plot must have a coherent structure , involving a series of events that are logically connected. A good plot has a beginning, middle, and end , with key moments like peripeteia and anagnorisis.
- What is Aristotle’s definition of ‘Tragedy’? Answer : Aristotle defines tragedy as the imitation of an action that is serious, complete, and of a certain magnitude , which evokes feelings of pity and fear in the audience, resulting in catharsis.
- How does Aristotle distinguish between ‘Epic Poetry’ and ‘Tragedy’? Answer : Aristotle distinguishes between the two based on scope and form. Epic poetry is long, covering a wide range of events, and usually told in narrative form. Tragedy is focused, concise, and structured with a clear beginning, middle, and end.
- What is the importance of ‘Character’ in tragedy? Answer : The character is essential in a tragedy because it drives the plot. The protagonist should have a tragic flaw (hamartia), which leads to their downfall, making the audience relate to and empathize with them.
- What role does ‘Spectacle’ play in a tragedy according to Aristotle? Answer : While spectacle (visual elements like costumes, sets, and physical action) can enhance the emotional impact of a play, Aristotle regards it as the least important element. Plot and character remain the core components of a tragedy.
- Explain the role of ‘Melody’ in Aristotle’s definition of tragedy. Answer : Melody refers to the musical elements of a tragedy, including the chorus. It
Answer : These concepts are key to the development of the tragic hero in Aristotle’s theory: ○ Hamartia is the tragic flaw or error in judgment that leads to the hero’s downfall. ○ Peripeteia is the reversal of fortune that changes the hero’s situation dramatically. ○ Anagnorisis is the moment of recognition , when the hero realizes their mistake or the true nature of their situation. These elements together structure the emotional intensity of the tragedy and contribute to the hero's downfall.
- Examine the differences between ‘Epic Poetry’ and ‘Tragedy’ as per Aristotle’s analysis. Answer : Aristotle distinguishes between epic poetry and tragedy by examining their forms, scope, and impact. Epic poetry is a long narrative form that spans a wider time frame and covers multiple characters. It allows more freedom in structure and plot. Tragedy , on the other hand, is more focused, often occurring in a single day or time frame, involving a single plot with a central protagonist. Aristotle argues that tragedy is superior because of its ability to evoke strong emotional reactions.
Multiple Choice Questions (MCQs)
Easy Level
- What is the most important element of a tragedy according to Aristotle?
○ A) Character ○ B) Plot ○ C) Diction ○ D) Spectacle ○ Answer : B) Plot ○ Explanation : Aristotle believed that plot is the most crucial element in a tragedy, as it drives the emotional and thematic impact.
- What does ‘Mimesis’ mean in Aristotle’s Poetics****?
○ A) Imitation of life ○ B) Moral lessons ○ C) Tragic flaw ○ D) Emotional release
○ Answer : A) Imitation of life ○ Explanation : Mimesis is the concept of imitation, where art reflects real-life actions, often to evoke specific emotions.
- What is the primary purpose of a tragedy according to Aristotle?
○ A) To entertain ○ B) To teach ○ C) To evoke pity and fear ○ D) To confuse the audience ○ Answer : C) To evoke pity and fear ○ Explanation : Tragedy aims to provoke strong emotional responses, which leads to catharsis.
Medium Level
- Which of the following is a key feature of ‘Catharsis’ in Aristotle's theory?
○ A) Audience feels anger ○ B) Audience experiences emotional release ○ C) Hero wins in the end ○ D) Tragedy evokes humor ○ Answer : B) Audience experiences emotional release ○ Explanation : Catharsis is the emotional purging of pity and fear experienced by the audience.
- What is ‘Hamartia’ in the context of Aristotle’s Poetics****?
○ A) Moment of recognition ○ B) A tragic flaw ○ C) The tragic hero’s downfall ○ D) The play’s moral message ○ Answer : B) A tragic flaw ○ Explanation : Hamartia is the error or flaw in the protagonist’s character that leads to their downfall.
- What is the purpose of ‘Spectacle’ in Aristotle's theory?
○ A) To evoke intellectual ideas ○ B) To engage through visual effects
- Which of the following best describes Aristotle’s ideal tragic hero?
○ A) A hero who is morally perfect. ○ B) A hero who suffers due to an external force. ○ C) A hero with a tragic flaw who experiences a downfall. ○ D) A hero who succeeds despite adversity. ○ Answer : C) A hero with a tragic flaw who experiences a downfall. ○ Explanation : Aristotle’s ideal tragic hero is a noble character with a tragic flaw (hamartia) that leads to their downfall , which evokes pity and fear in the audience.
- What is the role of the ‘Chorus’ in Aristotle’s Poetics****?
○ A) To provide the play’s moral message. ○ B) To narrate the entire plot. ○ C) To comment on the events of the play and reflect on the themes. ○ D) To offer a distraction from the main action. ○ Answer : C) To comment on the events of the play and reflect on the themes. ○ Explanation : The Chorus in a tragedy acts as a collective voice, offering commentary, reflecting on the moral and emotional aspects of the plot, and providing insight into the themes.
- According to Aristotle, what is the ideal length for a tragedy?
○ A) As long as possible to cover many events. ○ B) It should be long enough to allow the plot to unfold naturally and evoke emotions without being overly long. ○ C) It should be short, lasting less than an hour. ○ D) It should last for several days. ○ Answer : B) It should be long enough to allow the plot to unfold naturally and evoke emotions without being overly long. ○ Explanation : Aristotle emphasizes that a tragedy should not be too long or too short. It should be long enough to develop the plot and characters fully, while still maintaining the emotional impact.
Topic 2: Longinus: On the Sublime (Peri Hypsous)
Introduction to Longinus:
● Longinus is a Greek rhetorician and philosopher, best known for his treatise "On the Sublime" (Peri Hypsous) , which is considered one of the most influential works on the art of rhetoric and aesthetics in classical literature. ● The work is focused on the concept of the sublime in literature and rhetoric, which refers to the quality in speech or writing that transcends ordinary experience to evoke elevated emotions and inspire awe in the audience. ● Although Longinus is not a famous figure in his own right and much of his life remains unclear, his work has had a significant impact on both classical and modern literary criticism.
Key Concepts in "On the Sublime":
- The Sublime Defined:
○ According to Longinus, the sublime is a style of writing or speaking that is lofty, elevated, and powerful. It stirs deep emotions in the audience, leading to a sense of awe and admiration. ○ The sublime is not only a literary or rhetorical quality but also an emotional experience, making it one of the highest forms of expression in art.
- Sources of the Sublime:
○ Sublime thoughts : Great ideas or lofty subjects often elevate the text, giving it an exalted or noble tone. ○ Sublime emotions : The emotions conveyed in the work (like passion, love, grief ) are intense, affecting both the speaker and the audience. ○ Sublime language : The use of majestic, powerful, and expressive language that is able to capture the intensity of the subject and evoke strong feelings in the audience. ○ Sublime figures of speech : These include metaphors, similes, and other devices that create vivid, memorable, and emotionally charged imagery.
- The Role of Nature and Inspiration:
○ Longinus believes that the sublime cannot be artificially created. It emerges from the genuine power of the writer or speaker, inspired by a deep connection with nature or profound thoughts. ○ The influence of nature plays a pivotal role in inspiring great writers and speakers to reach sublime heights.
○ Longinus asserts that well-chosen metaphors, similes, and other figures of speech are crucial to evoke grandeur. These should not be mere decorative flourishes but should resonate with the underlying emotional and intellectual content of the work.
- Unity of Structure:
○ The work should maintain a coherent and unified structure to keep the audience engaged and ensure that the emotional highs are sustained. Disjointedness or lack of structure detracts from the sublime experience.
The Relationship Between Sublime and Rhetoric:
● Rhetoric , the art of persuasion, is deeply connected to the sublime. While rhetoric aims to persuade through logical argument and structure, the sublime focuses on inspiring awe and eliciting profound emotional responses. ● Longinus argues that when an orator or writer achieves the sublime, they do not need to rely on logical reasoning alone but on the sheer force of their expression to persuade and move the audience.
The Critique of Artificial Style:
● Longinus is highly critical of overly artificial or decorative styles of writing. He warns that excessive ornamentation or flowery language detracts from the potential of the work to be truly sublime. ● True sublimity, in his view, comes from the natural flow of ideas and emotions, which do not need to be burdened by overly intricate or forced language.
Key Figures Discussed in the Text:
Longinus discusses many great literary and rhetorical figures as examples of those who achieved the sublime. Some of these include:
● Homer : Known for the sublime nature of his epic poetry, especially in works like the Iliad and the Odyssey. ● Demosthenes : A renowned Greek orator whose speeches embodied emotional force and sublimity. ● Plato : Particularly in his dialogues, where elevated ideas and passions are presented in a way that inspires the reader.
Question Series for Exam Preparation:
Theoretical Questions
Very Short Answer Questions (1-2 Marks)
- Who is Longinus and what is his major work? Answer : Longinus was a Greek rhetorician and philosopher. His major work is "On the Sublime" ( Peri Hypsous ), which discusses the concept of the sublime in literature and oratory.
- What is the main idea behind the concept of the Sublime according to Longinus? Answer : The sublime is a literary or rhetorical quality that evokes deep emotions, such as awe and admiration, through the use of elevated ideas, passionate expression, and powerful language.
- Define ‘sublime language’ as per Longinus. Answer : Sublime language refers to powerful, elevated, and expressive language that conveys grandeur and emotion, aiming to inspire awe in the audience.
- What is the role of passion in achieving the sublime? Answer : Passion plays a crucial role in the sublime, as the expression of genuine, intense emotions enhances the power of the speech or writing, making it impactful and stirring for the audience.
- Which figures does Longinus refer to as examples of the sublime? Answer : Longinus refers to Homer , Demosthenes , and Plato as examples of figures who achieved the sublime in their works.
Short Answer Questions (3-4 Marks)
- Explain the five essential elements of the sublime according to Longinus. Answer : The five elements of the sublime are: ○ Grandeur of Thought (lofty ideas that evoke admiration). ○ Vigour of Passion (strong emotional expression). ○ Artful Expression (elevated and effective use of language). ○ Noble and Elevated Composition (clear, purposeful organization of ideas).
- What is the main focus of Longinus’ On the Sublime****?
○ A) History of literature ○ B) The importance of logic in speech ○ C) The concept of the sublime in literature and rhetoric ○ D) The role of mythology in literature ○ Answer : C) The concept of the sublime in literature and rhetoric
- Which of the following is an example of a source of the sublime?
○ A) Artificial language ○ B) Grandeur of thought ○ C) Excessive ornamentation ○ D) Lack of passion ○ Answer : B) Grandeur of thought
Medium Level
- According to Longinus, which of the following is a characteristic of sublime language?
○ A) It should be simple and plain. ○ B) It should be powerful and expressive. ○ C) It should use many metaphors. ○ D) It should avoid emotional appeal. ○ Answer : B) It should be powerful and expressive
- What is the role of ‘Figures of Speech’ in creating the sublime?
○ A) They should be used sparingly to add variety. ○ B) They help in creating emotional resonance and elevating the content. ○ C) They should be avoided in favor of plain speech. ○ D) They are only used for decorative purposes. ○ Answer : B) They help in creating emotional resonance and elevating the content.
