


Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Community
Ask the community for help and clear up your study doubts
Discover the best universities in your country according to Docsity users
Free resources
Download our free guides on studying techniques, anxiety management strategies, and thesis advice from Docsity tutors
A representative democracy is when citizens elect or choose a government officials to represent them in the lawmaking process. Those elected officials, called ...
Typology: Lecture notes
1 / 4
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!
Democracy is a form of government wherein citizens are allowed to govern themselves by participating in the formulation and passage of laws and in making governmental decisions. Although democracy had been practiced in many ancient civilizations, it was thought to have originated in ancient Greece particularly in the city state of Athens; Athenian democracy was a direct democracy.
Direct democracy is also known as pure democracy. In a direct democracy, citizens propose, decide, and change Constitutional laws; initiate referendums; and choose and remove public officials who are not effectively doing their jobs. It is practiced in only a few places, like Switzerland, where citizens approve laws using a single majority in the town or city levels, and a double majority at the national level. Laws are proposed by its citizens and must be approved by a majority of the voters. This type of system works best with smaller groups, where it is easy to hear every single person’s vote and voter participation is high.
A representative democracy is when citizens elect or choose a government officials to represent them in the lawmaking process. Those elected officials, called electors , are the ones to propose and approve laws based on the interests of the public that they are representing. This type of system is more effective in larger countries, where it would be difficult to gather each individual’s vote, or where voter participation is lower. In many countries, like the United States, electors are used on the national and state levels of government, but not used on the municipal (city or town) level.
While most developed countries today have representative democracies, there are both benefits and drawbacks to a system like this.
Advantages of a Representative Democracy
1. When operating as it should, it is a highly efficient form of government. Instead of forcing everyone to vote on everything, a representative democracy allows decisions to be made by a group of elected officials who can dedicate themselves full-time to the decision- making process. A representative democracy is often a desirable choice for larger countries where the logistics of voting are a long and painstaking process. Rather than waiting for each citizen to turn out to vote, shortcuts can be made to expedite the process. 2. People still have a voice. Although a representative democracy takes away the direct decision-making power of individuals, it does not completely eliminate their influence on the government. If the population is dissatisfied with the performance of their elected official, they can vote to remove that person on the next election cycle. 3. It can help everyone, even if they don’t participate in the political process. Elected officials are tasked with making decisions for their entire district or region. Everyone who lives in that area benefits from the decisions made by their representative. Even individuals who are not engaged in the political process benefit from this representation. For example, if the representative helps pass a law to lower taxes in that district, everyone benefits, even those who did not vote. 4. Controls can be put into place to limit the individual action of an elected official. Recall elections, which is when an official is voted to be removed from office, and other similar rules can be used within a representative democracy to allow a district to remove an elected official who is not meeting their expectations.
Disadvantages of a Representative Democracy
1. Trust is required to make this government structure work. Once an official is elected to represent them, the population must trust that their representative will work to do what is best for their constituents. Someone with a secret agenda could say one thing during an election, become a representative, and then pursue something entirely different than what their election campaign promised. 2. It can still be difficult to get things done. A clear majority does not usually rule in a representative democracy. There are many political parties in most systems that each have a specific platform of priorities they wish to pursue. When those platforms are opposing one another, it creates gridlock within the government that can stop some of the work from being done. 3. Representatives may not represent everyone. A common complaint about a representative democracy is that the elected officials are “out of touch.” This occurs because a representative must be present where the government meets, which could be thousands of miles away from their district where their constituents live. Some communities or districts may also have highly varied types of people that have conflicting needs, making it difficult for one elector to meet the needs of everyone. 4. In some ways, it discourages participation. When there is a representative democracy in place, people know that they will receive governmental representation, whether they choose to vote or not. For some, that means they choose not to participate in the voting process because they automatically receive this representation. Others choose not to participate because the officials running in an election do not represent their needs. Sometimes, because of the
In the chart below, identify whether each scenario is describing representative democracy (RD) or direct democracy (DD)
RD or DD? Scenario
For each scenario below, identify whether you think direct democracy or representative democracy would be the best system, and explain why.