Docsity
Docsity

Prepare for your exams
Prepare for your exams

Study with the several resources on Docsity


Earn points to download
Earn points to download

Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan


Guidelines and tips
Guidelines and tips

Corporate Restructuring Strategies and Compliances, Study Guides, Projects, Research of Law

An in-depth analysis of corporate restructuring strategies, their meanings, and their importance in the business world. It discusses various types of restructuring strategies such as mergers, acquisitions, and demergers, and their benefits. The document also highlights the compliance requirements under several statutes and the need for approvals from various authorities. It is a valuable resource for students and professionals interested in understanding corporate restructuring and its impact on business growth.

Typology: Study Guides, Projects, Research

2023/2024

Uploaded on 04/15/2024

hrithik-chormare
hrithik-chormare 🇮🇳

1 document

1 / 17

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
RESEARCH PROJECT
On
‘Need, Scope and Types of Corporate Restructuring Strategies’
Submitted to
MAHARASHTRA NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY, AURANGABAD
Submitted by
HRITHIK CHORMARE
B. A.LL.B. (Hons.) Semester-VIII
Roll No. 2020/BALLB/19
Paper 8.5: Corporate Restructuring and M & A.
Under the guidance of
Ms. Riya Jariwala
Assistant Professor of Economics
Maharashtra National Law University, Aurangabad
April, 2024
pf3
pf4
pf5
pf8
pf9
pfa
pfd
pfe
pff

Partial preview of the text

Download Corporate Restructuring Strategies and Compliances and more Study Guides, Projects, Research Law in PDF only on Docsity!

RESEARCH PROJECT

On

‘Need, Scope and Types of Corporate Restructuring Strategies’

Submitted to

MAHARASHTRA NATIONAL LAW UNIVERSITY, AURANGABAD

Submitted by

HRITHIK CHORMARE

B. A.LL.B. (Hons.) Semester-VIII

Roll No. 2020/BALLB/ 19

Paper 8. 5 : Corporate Restructuring and M & A.

Under the guidance of

Ms. Riya Jariwala

Assistant Professor of Economics

Maharashtra National Law University, Aurangabad

April, 202 4

Contents

  • Acknowledgement
  • ABSTRACT
    1. INTRODUCTION..............................................................................................................
    1. MEANING OF CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
    1. CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING AS A BUSINESS STRATEGY
    1. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING......................
    1. NEED & SCOPE FOR CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
    1. BENEFITS OF CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING.......................................................
  • RESTRUCTURING STRATEGIES 7. PLANNING, FORMULATION & EXECUTION OF VARIOUS CORPORATE
    1. TYPES OF CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING
  • RESTRUCTURING 9. REGULATORY FRAME OR LEGAL ASPECTS REGARDING CORPORATRE
    1. CONCLUSION

ABSTRACT

Corporate restructuring has no become one of the significant elements which play a very important role for a company to keep track with the environment. A strategy of corporate restructuring survives around Mergers, Demergers, Reverse Merger, Disinvestment, Take Overs, Acquisitions, Strategic Alliance etc., and while doing Corporate Restructuring, a company must comply with the compliances under several statutes like The Companies Act, , Income Tax Act, The Indian Stamp Act, The Competition Act etc., and moreover it also requires approvals from various authorities like NCLT, SEBI, Ministry of Corporate Affairs. In this paper the author has tried to explain the concept of corporate restructuring by explaining its Historical Background, its Business Strategy, Need & Scope, Benefits, Regulatory Framework or Legal Aspects in detail.

KEYWORDS:-

Corporate Restructuring, Merger, Companies, Competition.

1. INTRODUCTION

There are basically two ways of expansion or growth of business entities, i.e., organic and inorganic growth. Organic growth is through the internal strategies, which may relate to business or financial restructuring within an organization that results in enhanced & better customer base, higher sales, increased revenue, without resulting in change of corporate entity. Inorganic growth provides an organization with a method for attaining hasten growth accrediting to skip few steps on the growth ladder. Restructuring through mergers, amalgamations, etc., constitute one of the most important techniques for securing inorganic growth. A company is growing organically when the growth is through the internal sources without change in the corporate entity. Organic growth can be done through capital rebuilding or business restructuring. Inorganic growth is the rate of growth of the business by which there is an increasing in output and business reach, acquiring new businesses by way of mergers, acquisitions and take-overs and other corporate rebuilding Strategies which may create a change in a corporate entity. The business environment is quickly changing with respect to technology, competition, products, people, geographical area, markets, customers. It will not be enough if companies keep pace with these changes but are expected to beat competition and institute in order to continuously maximize shareholder value. Inorganic growth strategies like mergers, acquisitions, takeovers and spinoffs are regarded as important mechanism that help companies to enter new markets, expand customer base, cut competition, integrate and grow in size quickly, enlist new technology with respect to products, people and processes. Thus, the inorganic growth strategies are regarded as accelerated corporate restructuring strategies for growth for a company.

reduction of profit margins or decrease in the power of their corporate value. Thus, Restructuring is an inorganic growth strategy.^1

4. HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF CORPORATE

RESTRUCTURING

In earlier years, India was a highly regulated economy. Though Government participation was overwhelming, the economy was controlled in a centralized way by Government participation and intervention. In other words, economy was closed as economic forces such as demand and supply were not allowed to have a full-fledged liberty to rule the market. There was no scope of realignments and everything was controlled. In such a scenario, the scope and mode of Corporate Restructuring were very limited due to restrictive government policies and rigid regulatory framework. These restrictions remained in vogue, practically, for over two decades. These, however, proved incompatible with the economic system in keeping pace with the global economic developments if the objective of faster economic growth were to be achieved. The Government had to review its entire policy framework and under the economic liberalization measures removed the above restrictions by omitting the relevant sections and provisions. The real opening up of the economy started with the Industrial Policy, 1991 whereby 'continuity with change' was emphasized and main thrust was on relaxations in industrial licensing, foreign investments, transfer of foreign technology etc. With the economic liberalization, globalization and opening up of economies, the Indian corporate sector started restructuring to meet the opportunities and challenges of competition. The economic and liberalization reforms, have transformed the business scenario all over the world. The most significant development has been the integration of national economy with 'market-oriented globalized economy'. The multilateral trade agenda and the World Trade Organization (WTO) have been facilitating easy and free flow of technology, capital and expertise across the globe. A restructuring wave is sweeping the corporate sector the world over, taking within its fold both big and small entities, comprising old economy businesses, conglomerates and new economy companies and even the infrastructure and service sector. From banking to oil exploration and telecommunication (^1) Corporate Restructuring, Valuations, & Insolvency, Professional Programme, ICSI, Module - 3

to power generation, petrochemicals to aviation, companies are coming together as never before. Not only these new industries like e-commerce and biotechnology have been exploding and old industries are being transformed. With the increasing competition and the economy, heading towards globalisation, the corporate restructuring activities are expected to occur at a much larger scale than at any time in the past. Corporate Restructuring play a major role in enabling enterprises to achieve economies of scale, global competitiveness, right size, and a host of other benefits including reduction of cost of operations and administration.^2

5. NEED & SCOPE FOR CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING

The Corporate Restructuring process aims at enhancing economies of scale and attainment of efficiency. The survival and growth of companies in the competitive environment depends on their ability to pool all their resources for optimum use of maximize the value. For example, a new big company is created out of merger of small companies that can achieve economies of scale. Further, the enhanced corporate status allows it to leverage the same to its own advantage in the form of tapping national or international capital markets for funds at low cost. This availability of funds at lower rate certainly makes the company more comfortable and competitive. Therefore, the needs for corporate restructuring exercise are as follows: (i) To focus on core strengths. (ii) To achieve economies of scale by expanding to national and international markets. (iii) Attainment for operational synergy and efficient allocation of managerial capabilities and infrastructure. (iv) Ensuring constant supply of raw materials and access to R&D (v) Helps in reducing cost of capital (vi) Helps in revival & the rehabilitation of sick companies by adjusting losses of the sick units with profits of a healthy unit. (^2) Corporate Restructuring, Liquidation, Insolvency & Winding-Up, Professional Programme, ICSI, Module – 2, Corporate Restructuring, Valuations, & Insolvency, Professional Programme, ICSI, Module – 3, Merger Acquisition & Corporate Restructuring – Strategies & Practices, Taxmann, 3rd^ Edition.

Vodafone) iii. Reduced Competition – Horizontal merger helps companies in reduction of competition. Competition is the prime factor & the most common and strong grounds for mergers and acquisitions. (Ex: - HP and Compaq) iv. Tax benefits – Companies also use mergers and amalgamations for tax benefits. Mainly, where there is merger between profit making and lossmaking companies. Most of the income tax benefit arises from set-off and carry forward provision under the Income-tax Act, 1961.^4 v. Strong brand – Creation of the brand is a long process; hence, companies choose to obtain an established brand and take advantage of it to earn high profits. (Ex: - Tata Motors and Jaguar) vi. New Technology – Companies need to pay attention on technological developments and their business applications. The Acquisition of smaller companies helps the enterprises to control distinctive technologies and prosper a competitive edge over other companies. (Ex: - Dell and EMC ) vii. Domination – Companies get engaged in mergers and acquisitions to become a superior player or market leader in their particular sector. However, such supremacy shall be subject to regulations of the Competition Act,

  1. (Ex: - Oracle and I-Flex Technologies) viii. Revival of Sick Company – Today, the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 has created additional avenue of acquisition through the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process.

7. PLANNING, FORMULATION & EXECUTION OF

VARIOUS CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING STRATEGIES

Corporate restructuring strategies depends on the nature of business, type of diversity required and results in maximization of profit through merging of resources in effective manner, utilization of the idle resources, effective management of competition etc.,. Planning the type of restructuring requires detailed business study, expected business demand, available resources, utilized/idle portion of resources, competitor analysis, environmental impact etc., The bottom line is that the right restructuring strategy provides optimum synergy for the (^4) Section 72, Income Tax Act, 1961

organizations involved in the restructuring process. It involves examination of various aspects before and after the restructuring process.^5

8. TYPES OF CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING

There are various types of Corporate Restructuring which includes: -

1. MERGER Merger is the combination of two or more companies by way of amalgamation or absorption. It means that two companies get merged to earn high profits. Merger can be done in many ways: - i. Horizontal Merger - Two companies that are in direct competition and share the same product lines and markets i.e., it results in the consolidation of firms that are direct rivals. E.g., Exxon and Mobil, Ford and Volvo, Volkswagen. ii. Vertical merger- A customer and company or a supplier and company i.e., merger of firms that have actual or potential buyer-seller relationship e.g. Ford- Bendix. iii. Conglomerate merger- Generally a merger between companies which do not have any common business areas or no common relationship of any kind. Consolidated firm a may sell related products or share marketin g. iv. Concentric Mergers - Concentric mergers take place between firms that serve the same customers in a particular industry, but they don’t offer the same products and services. Their products may be complements, product which go together, but technically not the same products. For example, if a company that produces DVDs mergers with a company that produces DVD players, this would be termed as concentric merger, since DVD players and DVDs are complements products, which are usually purchased together. 2. DEMERGER Under this corporate rebuilding procedure, at least two organizations are joined into a solitary organization to get the advantage of cooperative energy emerging out of such merger. 3. REVERSE-MEREGER (^5) PP- CRVI - 2014, LESSON – 1 CORPORATE RESTRUCTURING – INTRODUCTION & CONCEPTS.

The following below mentioned is the scheme of Chapter XV. a. Section 230-231 deals with compromise or arrangements. b. Section 232 deals with mergers and amalgamations including demergers. c. Section 233 deals with amalgamation of small companies (also called fast track mergers). d. Section 234 deals with amalgamation of foreign companies (also called as cross border mergers). e. Section 235 deals with acquisition and dissenting of shareholders. f. Section 236 deals with purchase of minority shareholding. g. Section 237 deals with power of central government to provide for amalgamation of companies in public interest. h. Section 238 deals with registration of offer of schemes involving transfer of shares. i. Section 239 deals with preservation of books and papers of amalgamated companies. j. Section 240 deals with the liability of officers in respect of offences committed prior to merger, amalgamation etc. Salient Features of Companies Act, 2013: -

  • National Company Law Tribunal to assume jurisdiction of High Court.
  • Application for compromise or arrangement to be accompanied by an affidavit disclosing – 1. All materials facts relating to the company. 2. Reduction of Capital if any included in the Compromise or arrangement 3. Any scheme of corporate debt restructuring consented to by not less than 75% of the secured creditors in value along with creditors responsibility Statement, report of the auditor as to the fund’s requirement after CDR And the conformity to liquidity test etc^6.
  • Notice relating to compromise or arrangement and other documents to be placed on the website of the company^7.
  • Notice of meeting for approval of the scheme of compromise or arrangement be dent to various regulators including^8 1. The Central Government 2. Income Tax Authorities 3. Reserve Bank of India 4. Security Exchange Board of India 5. The Registrar 6. Respective Stock Exchange, etc. (^6) Section 230(2), Companies Act, 2013 (^7) Section 230(3), Companies Act, 2013 (^8) Section 230(5), Companies Act, 2013
  • Persons holding not less than 10% of the shareholdings or persons having outstanding debt amounting to not less than 5% of the total outstanding debt as per the latest audited financial statement, entitled to subject the scheme of compromise or arrangement. 9
  • No sanction for Compromise or arrangement if accounting treatment is no AS compliant.^10
  • Cross border Merger permitted. The 1956 act permits merger of foreign company with Indian company and not vice versa.^11
  • Abolishing the practice of companies holding their own shares through a trust (Treasury Stock) in case of merger of holding and subsidiary companies. Ultimately the shares are to be cancelled.^12
  • Fast track mergers introduced. – The new Act enables fast track merger without the approval of NCLT, between: 1. Two or more small companies. 2. Holding and wholly owned subsidiary companies. 3. Other classes of companies as may be prescribed^13
  • Approval of scheme by postal ballot thereby involving wider participation.^14 II. INCOME TAX ACT, 1961 Income Tax Act deals with the concept of amalgamating/amalgamated companies, carry forward of losses, exemptions from capital gains tax etc. A. If capital gains arise on transfer of any capital asset in the scheme of amalgamation, by an amalgamating company to the amalgamated company to the amalgamated company, such capital gains shall be exempt from tax provided the amalgamated company is an Indian company.^15 B. If capital gains arising on transfer of shares held in an Indian company by amalgamating foreign company to amalgamated foreign company, such capital gains shall be exempt from tax but there is a proviso to this exemption.^16 (^9) Section 230(4), Companies Act, 2013 (^10) Section 230(7), Companies Act, 2013 (^11) Section 234, Companies Act, 2013 (^12) Section 233(10), Companies Act, 2013 (^13) Section 233, Companies Act, 2013 (^14) Section 230(6), Companies Act, 2013 (^15) Corporate Restructuring – A measure to outlast ongoing distress, Income Tax Articles, Taxguru, Aayush Aggarwal, 2020 (^16) IBID
  1. Appreciable Adverse Effect - As per Section 3 of the Act, any agreement including cartel entered in respect of production, supply, distribution, storage, control etc. which directly or indirectly determines purchases and sale prices; limits or control production, supply, markets, technical development, investment or provision of services; directly or indirectly results in bid rigging or collusive bidding are presumed to have appreciable adverse effect on competition in India.^2223 In the case of Builders Association of India vs. Cement Manufacturers Association ,^24 the CCI held that the presumption of anticompetitive agreements can be inferred from the intention or conduct of the parties along with circumstantial evidence. In this case although there was no agreement, circumstantial evidence of parallel changes in the prices and production of goods indicated that the parties had form a cartel to determine purchase/sale prices and control production, supply, investment, development etc.
  2. Abuse of Dominant Position - As per Section 4 of the Act, dominant position is defined as a position of strength, enjoyed by an enterprise in the relevant market in India which enables the enterprise to operate independently of competitive forces in relevant market or can affect competitors, consumers or relevant market in its own favour. Imposing unfair or discriminatory condition or price in sale and purchase of goods and services; limiting or restricting production of goods, services, technical/scientific development; indulging in practice resulting to denial of market access; making conclusion of contracts subject to acceptance by other parties; or using its dominant position in one market to enter into another relevant market results in abuse of dominant position as per the Act^24. In the case of Shri Shamsher Kataria vs. Honda Siel Cars India Ltd & Ors ,^25 the CCI held that 14 car companies in India had abused their dominant position in their respective after markets by requiring customers to purchase spare parts and diagnostic tools solely from the respective car manufacturer or its authorized dealers.
  3. Transaction which qualifies as Combination cannot legally be consummated until the CCI grants its approval or the review period of 210 days as provided by the Act has expired^26 , whichever is earlier. Before such final verdict, the CCI is required to form a prima facie opinion on the Combination within a period of 30 working days from the notification^27. The CCI has the power to approve, disapprove or impose modification to a transaction.^28 IV. STAMP DUTY (^22) Competition Commission of India – Merger Control, Algo Legal, 4th (^) August, 2020. (^23) CompLR983(CCI) (^24) CompLR753(CCI) (^25) 2014 SCC OnLine CCI 95. (^26) Section 6(2), Competition Act, 2002 (^27) Regulation 19(1), Competition Commission of India (Procedure with regard to transaction of Business relating to combinations) Regulations, 2011. (^28) Section 31, Competition Act, 2002

Stamp duty provisions are regulated by “The Indian Stamp Act,1899 ” which is a Central enactment and the States are vested with powers either to adopt the said Stamp Act (with amendments, if any) or enact their own legislations governing payment of stamp duty on instruments. Section 3 of the Stamp Act is the main section which provides for levy of stamp duty on execution of an instrument. Three important factors for computing stamp duty are : a) There has to be an instrument b) Proper execution c) Rate of stamp duty applicable in the State where instrument is executed. JUDICIAL PRONOUNCEMENT OVER STAMP DUTY

  • Hindustan Lever Vs. State of Maharashtra^29 The Supreme Court of India held that a scheme sanctioned by the Court would be an ‘instrument’ and the state legislature has the competence to impose stamp duty on the order of amalgamation passed by the Court. The Supreme Court further held that. The foundation or the basis for passing an order of amalgamation is agreement between two or more companies. Under the Scheme of amalgamation, the whole or any part of the undertaking, properties or liability of any company concerned in the scheme is to be transferred to the other company. The scheme of amalgamation has its genesis in an agreement between the prescribed majority of shareholders and creditors of the transferor company with the prescribed majority of shareholders and creditors of the transferee company. The intended transfer is a voluntary act of the contracting parties. The transfer has all the trappings of a sale. The transfer is affected by an order of the Court.

10. CONCLUSION

Corporate Restructuring focuses on rebuilding a company & bring a significant change in structure of the organisation. It indicates towards revival of sick companies which are in loss for many years & corporate restructurings helps in reviving the companies & earning high profits. So, to restructure the company we need to know all the rules, regulations, needs & wants, acts, etc. The Paper reveals all the needs, Scope, types, historical background, regulatory framework or legal aspects of Corporate Restructuring. (^29) 2004(9) SCC 438