Download The Role of Judicial Precedents in the Indian Legal System and more Study notes Law in PDF only on Docsity!
Juditial Phaadont
Judderal huadmt^ is^ am^ mspnd^
onal saunu^ t laus^ n itiahAmpurlom^ a^ hgtbvn omd^ ojolalian,^ Tka^ dotlwne dudtinl pataduusd^ n^ anque^ Jeabue^ o^ nogish Lavi^ omd wmon LoN^ lomnes^ (u.SA^ tndn,^ Amdnola, lonada.^ al) n i^ Coninntel^ Couwlim0^ k^ FADnta, mony^ ond. Taly a^ Joclnime^ al^
tudiink paecadint^ hoas^ not^
han 6allnund Ahighn Count RpondvMknBiiitaa Pethn Meamig^ - A^ aneudont^ mms^ aeARL mslamce on case^ whidn^ s^ 0Y^ man^ a^ tokm a opoma 3 dicial_pasudo aa^ dociien^ A^
armpetemk- Cont
dunte apon^ a^ dspulad po^ o^ Aas ecmms^ mst wwly aguuid^ but^ am antbo^ owan N aniniig all Ata^ Couat^
imheniun tmisdkeuon^
aminisou MaAmme Aalm tull^ t^ mos n^ wml Pmlomi. Lmshn,^ ua^ eLan maams^ Ma guidanna ov^ adhosuly^ ol^ Past dacaon^ 4ev^ ulne^ aaes. Poslon m England - T m AAC m^ o^ Sptnln Couwbs A Supue Conf^ nmAsund^
AM drcisin
o A^ Auu^ Cam.^ dne (^) lo o^ Aimlan^ quisdisim mat umd^ g^ a.^ Asabiom^ e^ Ma Coucts^ Cnondendawmd
Heuse cfLnds(^ Seme^ Ceunt)
Cowntot riminat
Cent-fLApheal^ AppetlalëE Uniisinel
AphellliCownt^ ot^ APea Con ,
aATan Uimn
Qnaens Bench
Diusion
Prba Divnu
Amia
ChanyDialnm
Ceumby mls
Saprama kam ttdrt MassnnlE
Ce-ls
House o Lond^ (1)^ Tn^ Eglamd^ Ia^ wgkost^
aut
Hpuse Lnds^ (^ new^ {aS^
remCaut)
(2) Lts^ Jecsien^ bindumg^
on all^ mheun^ Cows.
3 In^ lh^ begimnima^
twas setileol^ 1hat^ Al
Hruse Lals^ ts^ bun^ ik^ on^
decsun
Attenney Genna.^ Deam^ at^ Winolsen^ (I8^ 6o)8^ HLe Land Cawnpbel In eomil&n V Beam Sh V&60) q4LC 2. Love
Can-pholl eilnnd k damma Viag sthongy
mby Csus^ ndn^ Tnduo^ entulaen
Suprme (nt
Highouu
Disctmk
Ma as lourt
(loura ik Fist
Tnsnce
Munsis un (Lunt Ant Tndona
(V The^ Co^ imins^ Atead^ ma^
dhsapd
iyons ned^ ov^ munapplisd^
a (^) Aa omel^ ma
ain hatoidin^ ti^
vi bs^ docisuiws
tonth au^
bound o^
oloci&Lei
lout (^) a Athesl,^ lou
imimAtal dte
ocston^ IHouse^
o Luos^
oam
Camt bound
(v) Simulan^
Counlan Counts^
anel Maiaa
CaAns ann^ baund^ Ay^
A dacste^ u}^ Sporn
n Cm
o &Tuon^ e^ readtnk^
ininelu :^ Beoe1q Te dotme^ at^
Btud qand^
amprlomte dunns
TButh (^) Yule In^ I8123^ MY^
Dom anggetid
AkatAaila
belane
md Argrstt^ t^
doiime udnt^
acqusd a^ mMnL
hgmfiamt plaa;^ but^
t gat a^ salalny^
Misgneu ky
S212 (e^ rovt^
Trda Att^ 193S^
ieh mnda^ Aa
Law dmd^ g^
Alefedunl
Coun and^ Phiy^
lounal
As hindin,^ m^
all Cans
AMA 19So:.
þrems ont^ At^
I41 H^
onsittom
Ina ovides^ Kat^
tLad dasnd^ Ag^
(a (^) Sp
ount shal^ e^ AAmin^
m all^ cowtt^ wuUtmn^ a^
tiny
Indis In^
Aagnning i^ as^ mst^
har whulL
Cown ne Beta^ Lmman^ o^ V,^
sTa e^ Biha^ (145T^
(.
661.) S.c, snmd
Cans
A
Tun netu Indam^ Coutti
Paew dacitim^ it^ t^ nvinud^ evneL^ and
X (V)^ The^ Wiglslumr^
y u beund^ Am^ h^ enm duns )ealy an^ stpal^ i^
heand (^) sy a^ wgh^ rege,^
m
abpeals Aneh^ as^ mmdn^
appeal, shecan^ eppeals^ sm^
kua
des, em^ Áme^
npaant nd^ tomkuhd^
Lkue ik
fT uae^ Called^
Dinfsn lenh^ onnd^
3 m^ nshlna
Fall Bench,^ Tke^
dacibuen uper^ emehin^
simdu
en tu^ Amalen^ Bindh. ) ABench^ iohtowmt^ ulhanla andintein^ met^ brund Jurishilm)^ Ae^ B
bkoa cous,-^ Au^ Ditc^
Cauts,Mogud
loud
Munsi Cors^ ane^ bnuyd^
a deaens^ a
amd High^ douw(w^
4urirdicaen) amd^
MniwMunsmd
sic n^ (ultm^
% Jmntdidem)
Doutne (^) a (^) Stane (^) Decisis The dene^ 'y^ applitab^ m^ Fngland^
os will^ s Inda This dodbhe dveloped as a neut tr made im^ Aas^ nepdung.^ The^ enin^ ot^ rneholr decaien an Englad Conbe^ Tntud^ patk^ o^ A^ 17A^ talw
ed amd^ weu^ qen^
a (^) nng na^ In1833,Ch^ Jua
Paak neiiau^ L^ ne^
Aatogmdit la^ indwnt
Kennel K^ utbLskments^
Highluw of^ Jditalu
by ta^ AtF1EH^ md!67s^
taltishd MTa^ dottaumt
Sar decisin^ was^ im^
Asabljaud avmd^ nw
a
Meanin o^ Slane^ decisis-^
t meoms esndecisn aland^ s^ aihtl
placa. when^ a^
decision (etauns
ane Pindplo,^ tu^
smoung on^ a
snbrdnela Ceunts^ amd walentteuls.^ Ths^
hmle sased^ on
has hesasive^ authnt^
n eqe
xpedien n^ puue^ poluey^
The oanaten^ of^
tha delhure^ aF
stae deuiso^ asapposes^ ta^
hinrchy ot^ te^ Court,^
The geeal
otma. m^
deciss is based^ ma
PAle m^ which^
aha dodne be staad^ as^ beleur )Each ourt^ is^ absslutely^
bound (^) ary the^ decisin^ sf^
te Cor
abevet. Even dilin
odict AMa
SC whecld
To a^ laim^
cxtent higun^ Couds^
anekund koy heu
0n deCSiens,^ In^ Inda,^
hayoeer ha^ S.C.^ u^ not^
brund
plwed by^ eum^
decisnms, athaus^ t^ t^
ehangitidecisiantjuta. kleysta tollswed Couui, (SanwamLannbav, ngUnen
Lndin ((195SC.
- Similas^ m^
Lnda, Aa^ deisim^ om^
one (^) H:C. nof
bindinan^ dhen^ 4iah^
Couni.
(4)A Smgla^ Btnth^ udga'ybemd^ Ay^
a decisisn^
a
Division Bendh^ ome^ Hc^
md Diysim^ Benc^ by^ ma
Full Benth
The Snpreme^ Cout^ m^ Sprene^ lent^
Advnales on (^) kewd Associatuen^ V.niem^ Inca^ (^ /^
Prpptrine S.C. (^) 268) held
hat lta^ dectine^ f^ sttnedecisis^ Agnet^ an^ nflaxibla hule amal^ it^ ha^ htla^ halavance^ n^ tsnlitunal^ asg,
.(4) fALadent Sailuuo an point t
low amwled m a Cane
S) Decauin 4wly ivtd out- T my
A lli^ tou-^ ana^ y^ ivdud diniss pealtpesl^ anddsll tra deaiem^ «helud^ agamt^
o cauty decnd
Nmalh dgs^ m^
abnn (^) ne al wmsu
ennwwr, brwr
RedennisCb^
frnens Decen^
The decisionsuml
m mimv The decaAesuml
en mistncevA
nalts or^ m^ Coniek^
wlk undamen
pnalu
tlowed
tw lo^
netlued la. Tun^ bianding^ torta^ botit
(7 AbroqaA^
Decikn A^ decom^
Cnae
nwagmhowH
A deeidsm
Mtnconsistnt
wut it^ lseqtdly-
nactnA
.oahayall. Al^
aMshd'sase^ sno^ he^
utralaed by
kwok A^193
amd 1930)
(
Aiuhen oy^ Revensal
anantud^ mund,
tun
iknamdr ealhin o
o ARveA
enenl-
uen ub,^
me uemet
mat daived
e authanuty^
bkA^
sudbdequkCouut^ m^
k
aMeurhta
atular pom^
ch khe^ nhe^
CauntdA
10 Ratio Declendi
Tt means eason ofthedeistn
thegeneral þrinipla^ whlcdh^ s^
deducad (^) fom 0 a Case In^ the^ Case^
TweddleV. Atkinsen
he Cowht^ Appeal^ deidad^ hat,^
bhe namgo
who s^ net^ a-^ þaki^
to tho^ Conkat^ can^ mot
u on^ tha^ bas^4
That Contnnty allihough
he may^ be^
bhu henifian^ hat^ contmetl^
tha
ivly of^
Centvact uk^ rugus^ the^ oaly^
an
abell among^ u^
bartis hu^ cnlat)^
the ana
hub usay^ obpliad^
an Jamna lay^ V.^ Ram^
AvtaCRc)
by ha^ Prwy^ anal.^
Tn aubstquant^
casns n
the dame^
pruneiple thu^
Aam Ala^
alflile
So he^ ato^
deuolends ss^ h^
Aule (^) l laus
Uhich zha^
deeistan ta^ Cast^
s frundad^ n.
Disinchan between^
RtioRato^ DeciolondiDeclondi
and Res Tuelicala
Ratio Decilnd^
Ls the^ prinuse amo vt becones a as a^ nuule^ e^
law and^
becomes an
aulhorrly fr^
AnbeagusntCases,^
mVelung Tha
Rylamd v^ Flechue^ h
AAmeprentple,^
. p Rylane^ V^
Aechsn ha hon. tha
guwen he^ nul^
Ihiet Aiasilk,^
hon tha
by The^
odfandartCausy on nalonal.
nse (^) by Zha^ dfndart
Caus
damases to^
Ah plainlyff^ by^
iescafe.
AV the hula sct iabt l n& te apicable, for his huason sa
M.C. Mekta^ v.^ voT hne no^ ese 4 the eum (^) gas hun the^ pumiy^ f^
dafendat, bat alainl use wa made^ hiabla;^ sticy^
apeakmg the
naliunLlatt
ta ule^ e^
Rylamd v.^ Fletho^
wa natnat^ aphliaka;apfliak
Ma S.C.^ udges distinguished^
he are^ m
Jos Cha^ channge^
amalial fact^ that^
thethe daend ddend-
activdy antan^ Lompamy^ wrs^
Anvslvesl anhazarlou
activi
bynsmg he^ slelm^
gas hich^
whrch issas
Sonous and^
olangelous n^
ndwra, Ao^
ha
Aiabildp io^ nt^
shietonfinedZo^
esate
nlure, so the
rem
ho premise)^ bt^
absrlule- laLilkz
even whput^ any^
esae (on^ tha^
hemises The
dehnolant ). Now Tha^ vueo^
Ryland v.^ Fletehe
wllpply^
wlk (^) () non nahal^ we^
nd (^) (i) escpa
hat umg^ prom^
the hemi^ seo^ dhendanT
(tha Rland^ v.^ Flecher)
But wken-^ the^ ha3aeloud^
aduvy S (^) mvoed, n n.c.Mekta^ v. UOT,^ th^ less 6v damaye^ to^ plaintjf^ s^
4utreient eren^ wdht
SCpe Ho^ nemuses^ oln^ (^
nthe pnmu oemoank albo) Rtio^ aaluie^ iabibt
Compensahon fov denth Can set
be claimsl an toyt
lo esonals -
Kose V Forol Less ey mal expecta tom a
Cenhmet
Danag an^ uen
Cempensalem nl,^ but aishnau a chaqub bemb etes be2suse nsas lvss ts la fumamca
n The manket
Theordes (^) About (^) the (^) Fundiom o ThaRaRa of Tudgesi- Judad (') (^) Decaralany (^) Thaory- Hau, Blacksloe aand Canl aA mam exponent otis Ahaur. Hala Conkidndat
ue Paniamint alena Asaralalis, an Ali shit are A Ag
xpouno law.^ Th^ an^ tndus^ Mi^ Law,^ LecanThe
apac canaed^ handdsuip^ m^ VaieA^ alitm^ -ve
lyuns am^ Auo^ h^ mans^ &mmk^ decMsn^
sbeslas
Aulsaspeddvel. fr s uaren la U.S. aurme^ Counk
has Guiem ala^ c9tttional^ ecasntn^ &Aadlina
t. 6na^ dodaem^ (Gta^ Nerlku^ v.^ aunsh^ id
andozo Salnse.^ The^ Casr^ atou^ la delminael nds^ Ai^ slA^ paint^ bu^ Cmem^ n hat (^) twwne. can^ wledeciosd,^ arlod^ ula
Lika U.S. amd Elomd ,Indian&vem Cot aoo nuiud M dainm o bdpectnmmkng m (^) GulekNalk Cra and avamamd^ fhaims
dedanelo Mas leca Apn+i
w3Aenalumm make^ Jaud^ y^ mw^ Shar
(yThe Ondgmal Law MakTheaa- L Bacem, Dilag q*
amd Sumend^ Awppor^ thin^ tkaort.^ Tha^ qusgs^ ma^ ka
w t^ Aaml^ tna^ m^ with^ t^ lsnlti^
matat, Tha
Spporns th^ Ak^ a^ mot^ ewnerm
m (^) Mlaing lau.^ Enph Law^ Aemmls^ Cad^
as udg^ -wads
lau Aactually^ a^ judzo^
do dadana^ M^ exsta Js mak lao,^
Jughes sut at Aka^ Aam^ am^ Andges
MJ m^ Kumvead^
Baa V.^ stt^ d^
nls(11735C!V
datinmuned (^) A (ontstatim^ o^
in A^ tamn^ apet
Th law^ ctig^
mtion al^ Coun^ spee^ a mawes dn MM
drc n
euws n^ aisene^
AGams m^ ixactim^ Au^
Sama
mse (^) ao i^ mgamwtioh^ is^
d uiklT newn ama^ adinam^ Amse^
e amd^ a
Dermenty (e law 1he laAae^ law^ A»^ lKe^ galA^ in^ Jte^ mine,wula.^
orluh
A
Ju (^) eny Volamin^ ow land (^) Mpery totai^ a^ tamu^ las,^ Aht^
tbenas pindl
dipeialt^ d^
w- o panticulan^ ton^ uomu
hluck PrMock^ conaiotucd^
Aa aw^ is^ ncompel 2 avse aken^ mmty^
conadnsndn suly thae^ faus
- Arvdrig^ Ay^
Ae fundammentl^ auu^
nuil
Aa la^ mus^
Aa Rnon^ Aul^
F ach
Lmhanuad Thu^ te^
Aaw alwan^ Lsat^ hato.^
[ Ray
decdlud Ain^ a^
tndamtwas^
Adinlhulhinbla
Futeur (^) a www)^ me^
msm Conabuun
Nvol The noness
deeisany a^ AL^
Swpeniv Lon
ntt uham n
oleede. S ha^ dwelopmwt^
etlas taough^ Ca^ law^
mu nough Casdaw^
mnL
ntigtnem n^ om^
npovwi lpal^ sne,^
AR towt
phulnha atut^
opporany &^ ui^
puadtwoeuudvon
ttut powmt^ omA^ mo^
wa law^ ull^ h^
Availalnvailakl
m tt SS
%BeUKom huds^ Mat^ judid^
puctt
a Canur ( bkn^
hnudn.^ Thu^ uaps^
o wot^ Aeopsnle
Plicopinum md^ putsionel^ opinisn^ f^
Ban. Moraove
agn loma^ ma^ pAs^ aiin^ asamst^
kn
Tt i dHicut mmk a oloe at dor Ae^ vadly^ lud^ nade^ hy^ cane^ auo.^ Amld
drpnd wpon le
18
numurtan wid^ A^ padmk
Mr d^ wino^ de^ idadA^ M^
adiw Thubin
wantg antin^ þomt,^ ha^
MaonalleneR md
fe (^) Valdw alau^ nada^ gudi&A^
uAanks aluey
onnd
naims a^ dasatalle^ s
Cemclustm Dn^ Mm^ Mas^
nightls
ossanvadtht attttalLehs mmpovlomca ua pacadort
Aldina ecause^ a^
thoug wmpreCadnad^ qnewth^ o-Ao
epont en^ n^
t shal^ wana^
imaln am^ ekte^ s
Dachne stns^
dacisguts luta
develobmow. Tha^ igdy^
Ma dseune^ mAy^ be^
mgall
y Mka^
SGGo a^ anm
daem ov^ a^ decA
