Docsity
Docsity

Prepare for your exams
Prepare for your exams

Study with the several resources on Docsity


Earn points to download
Earn points to download

Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan


Guidelines and tips
Guidelines and tips

Means-End Analysis of Outdoor Bound Course: Outcomes, Benefits, and Values, Lecture notes of Advanced Education

The linkages between the attributes of an Outward Bound course and the benefits, consequences, and personal values obtained by participants through means-end analysis. The study examines how completing the course leads to higher-level outcomes and personal values.

What you will learn

  • What are the core values of Outward Bound programs and how do they contribute to the quality of outdoor education?
  • How do participants link original outcomes to higher-level outcomes and personal values?
  • What are the key outcomes obtained from completing an Outward Bound course?

Typology: Lecture notes

2021/2022

Uploaded on 09/27/2022

deville
deville 🇺🇸

4.7

(23)

396 documents

1 / 8

Toggle sidebar

This page cannot be seen from the preview

Don't miss anything!

bg1
UNDERSTAND�USINGUSING MEANS-ENDMEANS-END THEORYTHEORY TOTO UNDERSTAND
EXPERIENCE�THETHE OUTDOOROUTDOOR ADVENTUREADVENTURE EXPERIENCE
MamieMamie GoldenbergGoldenberg DavidDavid KlenoskyKlenosky LeoLeo McAvoyMcAvoy andand TomTom HolmanHolman
GreenGreen Mt.Mt. CollegeCollege PurduePurdue UniversityUniversity UniversityUniversity
ofof
MinnesotaMinnesota
INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTION
AccordingAccording toto FordFord (1981),(1981), outdooroutdoor educa-
out-� odologyodology knownknown asas ladderingladdering werewere developeddeveloped toto
educa-� Means-endMeans-end theorytheory andand itsits associatedassociated meth-meth-
tiontion isis "education"education in,in, about,about, andand forfor thethe out-
reason"� understandunderstand howhow consumersconsumers thinkthink aboutabout productsproducts
doors,doors, implyingimplying aa place,place, aa topic,topic, andand aa reason"
..(p.(p. 14).14). AnotherAnother workingworking definitiondefinition statedstated thatthat oror servicesservices (Gutman,(Gutman, 1982;1982; ReynoldsReynolds && Gut-Gut-
outdooroutdoor educationeducation isis
"an"an
experientialexperiential methodmethod
ofof
man,man, 1988).1988). "Means-end"Means-end theorytheory seeksseeks toto
charac~charac~
learninglearning whichwhich takestakes placeplace primarilyprimarily throughthrough terizeterize thethe relationshipsrelationships amongamong particularparticular objectsobjects
sensorysensory involvementinvolvement withwith thethe out-of-doors"out-of-doors" oror behaviors,behaviors, 'the'the means,'means,' andand thethe outcomesoutcomes andand
(priest(priest && Gass,Gass, 1997,1997, p.p. 17).17). PriestPriest andand GassGass personalpersonal valuesvalues importantimportant toto thethe individual,individual,
'the'the
alsoalso defineddefined outdooroutdoor adventureadventure programsprograms asas ends'"ends'" (Klenosky,(Klenosky, Frauman,Frauman, Norman,Norman, &&
thosethose thatthat useuse challengingchallenging experiencesexperiences inin thethe Gengler,Gengler, 1998,1998, p.p. 27).27). MoreMore specifically,specifically, thethe
outdoorsoutdoors toto promotepromote personalpersonal andand groupgroup devel-devel- theorytheory characterizescharacterizes thethe relationshipsrelationships amongamong
opment.opment. threethree keykey concepts:concepts: attributes,attributes, consequences,consequences, andand
personalpersonal values.values. AttributesAttributes referrefer toto thethe charac-charac-
ThisThis researchresearch developeddeveloped aa betterbetter under-�under- teristicsteristics
ofof
thethe productproduct oror service.service. ForFor anan Out-Out-
standingstanding
ofof
thethe linkageslinkages betweenbetween outdooroutdoor adven-adven-� wardward BoundBound course,course, somesome
ofof
thethe attributesattributes in-in-
and� cludeclude thethe lengthlength
ofof
thethe course,course, locationlocation
ofof
thethe
tureture programprogram (Outward(Outward Bound)Bound) experiencesexperiences and
Previously� course,course, activitiesactivities donedone whilewhile
onon
course,course, andand thethe
outcomesoutcomes usingusing means-endmeans-end analysis.analysis. Previously
thethe means-endmeans-end approachapproach hadhad beenbeen usedused toto under-under-� numbernumber
ofof
individualsindividuals inin thethe group.group. Conse-Conse-
participation� quencesquences referrefer toto thethe benefits,benefits, whichwhich areare thethe de-de-
standstand thethe outcomesoutcomes
ofof
recreationalrecreational participation
1997;� siredsired outcomes,outcomes, andand alsoalso costs/risks,costs/risks, oror undesir-undesir-
inin aa ropesropes coursecourse programprogram (Goldenberg(Goldenberg 1997;
Goldenberg,Goldenberg, Klenosky,Klenosky, O'Leary,O'Leary, && Templ.in,�Templ.in, ableable outcomes.outcomes. ConsequencesConsequences forfor anan OutwardOutward
2000).2000).
ToTo
date,date, however,however, means-endmeans-end analysisanalysis� BoundBound coursecourse maymay
bebe
thatthat participantsparticipants learnlearn toto
of�
workwork together,together, learnlearn skillsskills thatthat neededneeded toto
hadhad notnot beenbeen usedused toto examineexamine thethe outcomesoutcomes
of
areare
.. broaderbroader outdooroutdoor programprogram experiences,experiences, suchsuch asas anan limi-
functionfunction inin thethe outdooroutdoor setting,setting, oror
justjust
learnlearn limi-
OutwardOutward BoundBound course.course. AccordingAccording toto Golden-Golden- .. tationstations andand strengthsstrengths asas anan individualindividual oror group.group.
bergberg etet aI.aI. (2000),(2000), "additional"additional researchresearch shouldshould bebe PersonalPersonal valuesvalues referrefer toto "highly"highly abstractabstract conse-conse-
conductedconducted toto betterbetter understandunderstand thisthis benefitbenefit andand quencesquences thatthat summarizesummarize desireddesired end-statesend-states
ofof
determinedetermine itsits rolerole andand generalizabilitygeneralizability inin otherother
......
being"being" (Goldenberg(Goldenberg etet aI.,aI., 2000,2000, p.p. 212).212). ValuesValues
adventureadventure educationeducation settings"settings" (p.(p. 221-222).221-222). thatthat maymay
bebe
importantimportant forfor OutwardOutward BoundBound par-par-
ticipantsticipants includeinclude aa sensesense
ofof
belonging,belonging, excite-excite-
BACKGROUNDBACKGROUND ment,ment, self-fulfillment,self-fulfillment, funfun andand enjoymentenjoyment oflife,oflife,
andand aa sensesense
ofof
accomplishment.accomplishment.
expanded�ResearchResearch inin outdooroutdoor educationeducation hashas expanded
an� RatherRather thanthan treatingtreating thesethese threethree elements,elements,
overover thethe pastpast severalseveral yearsyears andand therethere hashas beenbeen an
outcomes� thethe attributes,attributes, consequences,consequences, andand values,values, asas in-in-
increasedincreased emphasisemphasis
onon
examiningexamining thethe outcomes
ofof
outdooroutdoor educationeducation experiences.experiences. Means-end�Means-end dependentdependent
ofof
eacheach other,other, means-endmeans-end theorytheory isis
analysisanalysis goesgoes beyondbeyond lookinglooking simplysimply atat the� basedbased onon thethe viewview thatthat thesethese threethree elementselements areare
the
educa-� fundamentallyfundamentally interrelated.interrelated. Specifically,Specifically, accord-accord-
benefitsbenefits fromfrom participatingparticipating inin anan outdooroutdoor educa-
the� inging toto thethe theory,theory, product/serviceproduct/service attributesattributes rep-rep-
tiontion experience.experience. Means-endMeans-end theorytheory examinesexamines the
higher-� resentresent thethe "means""means"
byby
whichwhich consumersconsumers obtainobtain
linkageslinkages betweenbetween thethe benefitsbenefits andand otherother higher-
values.� desireddesired consequences/benefitsconsequences/benefits (as(as wellwell asas avoidavoid
levellevel outcomesoutcomes andand importantimportant personalpersonal values. im-undesiredundesired consequences/costs)consequences/costs) andand achieveachieve im-
40�40
pf3
pf4
pf5
pf8

Partial preview of the text

Download Means-End Analysis of Outdoor Bound Course: Outcomes, Benefits, and Values and more Lecture notes Advanced Education in PDF only on Docsity!

USINGUSING MEANS-ENDMEANS-END THEORYTHEORY TOTO UNDERSTANDUNDERSTAND

THETHE OUTDOOROUTDOOR ADVENTUREADVENTURE EXPERIENCEEXPERIENCE

MamieMamie GoldenbergGoldenberg DavidDavid KlenoskyKlenosky LeoLeo McAvoyMcAvoy andand TomTom HolmanHolman

GreenGreen Mt.Mt. CollegeCollege PurduePurdue UniversityUniversity UniversityUniversity ofof MinnesotaMinnesota

INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTION

AccordingAccording toto FordFord (1981),(1981), outdooroutdoor educa

out odologyodology knownknown asas ladderingladdering werewere developeddeveloped toto

educa Means-endMeans-end theorytheory andand itsits associatedassociated methmeth

tiontion isis "education"education in,in, about,about, andand forfor thethe out

doors,doors, implyingimplying aa place,place, aa topic,topic, andand aa reason"reason" understandunderstand howhow consumersconsumers thinkthink aboutabout productsproducts

..(p.(p. 14).14). AnotherAnother workingworking definitiondefinition statedstated thatthat oror servicesservices (Gutman,(Gutman, 1982;1982; ReynoldsReynolds && GutGut

outdooroutdoor educationeducation isis "an"an experientialexperiential methodmethod ofof man,man, 1988).1988). "Means-end"Means-end theorytheory seeksseeks toto charac~charac~

learninglearning whichwhich takestakes placeplace primarilyprimarily throughthrough terizeterize thethe relationshipsrelationships amongamong particularparticular objectsobjects

sensorysensory involvementinvolvement withwith thethe out-of-doors"out-of-doors" oror behaviors,behaviors, 'the'the means,'means,' andand thethe outcomesoutcomes andand

(priest(priest && Gass,Gass, 1997,1997, p.p. 17).17). PriestPriest andand GassGass personalpersonal valuesvalues importantimportant toto thethe individual,individual, 'the'the

alsoalso defineddefined outdooroutdoor adventureadventure programsprograms asas ends'"ends'" (Klenosky,(Klenosky, Frauman,Frauman, Norman,Norman, &&

thosethose thatthat useuse challengingchallenging experiencesexperiences inin thethe Gengler,Gengler, 1998,1998, p.p. 27).27). MoreMore specifically,specifically, thethe

outdoorsoutdoors toto promotepromote personalpersonal andand groupgroup develdevel theorytheory characterizescharacterizes thethe relationshipsrelationships amongamong

opment.opment. threethree keykey concepts:concepts: attributes,attributes, consequences,consequences, andand

personalpersonal values.values. AttributesAttributes referrefer toto thethe characcharac

ThisThis researchresearch developeddeveloped aa betterbetter underunder teristicsteristics ofof thethe productproduct oror service.service. ForFor anan OutOut

standingstanding ofof thethe linkageslinkages betweenbetween outdooroutdoor advenadven wardward BoundBound course,course, somesome ofof thethe attributesattributes inin

and cludeclude thethe lengthlength ofof thethe course,course, locationlocation ofof thethe tureture programprogram (Outward(Outward Bound)Bound) experiencesexperiences and

Previously course,course, activitiesactivities donedone whilewhile onon course,course, andand thethe outcomesoutcomes usingusing means-endmeans-end analysis.analysis. Previously

thethe means-endmeans-end approachapproach hadhad beenbeen usedused toto underunder numbernumber ofof individualsindividuals inin thethe group.group. ConseConse

standstand thethe outcomesoutcomes ofof recreationalrecreational participationparticipation quencesquences referrefer toto thethe benefits,benefits, whichwhich areare thethe dede

inin aa ropesropes coursecourse programprogram (Goldenberg(Goldenberg 1997;1997; siredsired outcomes,outcomes, andand alsoalso costs/risks,costs/risks, oror undesirundesir

Goldenberg,Goldenberg, Klenosky,Klenosky, O'Leary,O'Leary, && Templ.in,Templ.in, ableable outcomes.outcomes. ConsequencesConsequences forfor anan OutwardOutward

2000).2000). ToTo date,date, however,however, means-endmeans-end analysisanalysis BoundBound coursecourse maymay bebe thatthat participantsparticipants learnlearn toto

hadhad notnot beenbeen usedused toto examineexamine thethe outcomesoutcomes ofof workwork together,together, learnlearn skillsskills thatthat areare neededneeded toto

.. broaderbroader outdooroutdoor programprogram experiences,experiences, suchsuch asas anan functionfunction inin thethe outdooroutdoor setting,setting, oror justjust learnlearn limilimi-

OutwardOutward BoundBound course.course. AccordingAccording toto GoldenGolden .. tationstations andand strengthsstrengths asas anan individualindividual oror group.group.

bergberg etet aI.aI. (2000),(2000), "additional"additional researchresearch shouldshould bebe PersonalPersonal valuesvalues referrefer toto "highly"highly abstractabstract conseconse

conductedconducted toto betterbetter understandunderstand thisthis benefitbenefit andand quencesquences thatthat summarizesummarize desireddesired end-statesend-states ofof

determinedetermine itsits rolerole andand generalizabilitygeneralizability inin otherother...... being"being" (Goldenberg(Goldenberg etet aI.,aI., 2000,2000, p.p. 212).212). ValuesValues

adventureadventure educationeducation settings"settings" (p.(p. 221-222).221-222). thatthat maymay bebe importantimportant forfor OutwardOutward BoundBound parpar

ticipantsticipants includeinclude aa sensesense ofof belonging,belonging, exciteexcite

BACKGROUNDBACKGROUND

ment,ment, self-fulfillment,self-fulfillment, funfun andand enjoymentenjoyment oflife,oflife,

andand aa sensesense ofof accomplishment.accomplishment.

ResearchResearch inin outdooroutdoor educationeducation hashas expandedexpanded

an

RatherRather thanthan treatingtreating thesethese threethree elements,elements, overover thethe pastpast severalseveral yearsyears andand therethere hashas beenbeen an

outcomes

thethe attributes,attributes, consequences,consequences, andand values,values, asas inin increasedincreased emphasisemphasis onon examiningexamining thethe outcomes

ofof outdooroutdoor educationeducation experiences.experiences. Means-endMeans-end

dependentdependent ofof eacheach other,other, means-endmeans-end theorytheory isis

analysisanalysis goesgoes beyondbeyond lookinglooking simplysimply atat the

basedbased onon thethe viewview thatthat thesethese threethree elementselements areare the

educa

fundamentallyfundamentally interrelated.interrelated. Specifically,Specifically, accordaccord benefitsbenefits fromfrom participatingparticipating inin anan outdooroutdoor educa

the

inging toto thethe theory,theory, product/serviceproduct/service attributesattributes reprep tiontion experience.experience. Means-endMeans-end theorytheory examinesexamines the

higher

resentresent thethe "means""means" byby whichwhich consumersconsumers obtainobtain linkageslinkages betweenbetween thethe benefitsbenefits andand otherother higher

values.

desireddesired consequences/benefitsconsequences/benefits (as(as wellwell asas avoidavoid levellevel outcomesoutcomes andand importantimportant personalpersonal values.

undesiredundesired consequences/costs)consequences/costs) andand achieveachieve imim

USINGUSING MEANS-ENDMEANS-END THEORYTHEORY TOTO UNDERSTANDUNDERSTAND THETHE OUTDOOROUTDOOR ADVNETUREADVNETURE EXPERIENCEEXPERIENCE

portantportant personalpersonal valuesvalues oror "ends""ends" (Gutman(Gutman

Means-endMeans-end theorytheory hashas typicallytypically beenbeen appliedapplied

toto betterbetter understandunderstand consumerconsumer decision-makingdecision-making

behaviorbehavior inin aa varietyvariety ofof product/serviceproduct/service settings.settings.

ForFor example,example, means-endmeans-end studiesstudies havehave beenbeen concon

ductedducted toto examineexamine thethe factorsfactors involvedinvolved inin purpur

chasingchasing aa greetinggreeting cardcard (Walker(Walker &.&. Olson,Olson, 1991),1991),

.. selectingselecting aa skiski destinationdestination (Klenosky,(Klenosky, Gengler,Gengler,

&& Mulvey,Mulvey, 1993),1993), selectingselecting aa springspring breakbreak

destinationdestination (Klenosky,(Klenosky, 2002),2002), andand selectingselecting

amongamong statestate parkpark interpretiveinterpretive programsprograms

(Klenosky(Klenosky etet aI.,aI., 1998).1998). TheThe means-endmeans-end apap

proachproach waswas alsoalso appliedapplied toto exam.ineexam.ine ropesropes coursecourse

outcomesoutcomes (Goldenberg(Goldenberg 1997;1997; GoldenbergGoldenberg etet aI.,aI.,

2000).2000). TheThe currentcurrent studystudy waswas uniqueunique inin thatthat itit

waswas thethe fITstfITst applicationapplication ofof means-endmeans-end theorytheory toto

involveinvolve outdooroutdoor adventureadventure programming.programming. ItIt waswas

alsoalso uniqueunique inin thatthat itit appliedapplied means-endmeans-end theorytheory

toto understandunderstand thethe factorsfactors associatedassociated withwith concon

sumptionsumption oror participationparticipation ratherrather thanthan thosethose inin

volvedvolved inin productproduct oror serviceservice decision-making.decision-making.

PURPOSEPURPOSE OFOF STUDYSTUDY

TheThe researchresearch reportedreported herehere builtbuilt onon thethe

foundationfoundation ofof thethe earlierearlier ropesropes coursecourse studystudy byby

examiningexamining aa broaderbroader outdooroutdoor adventureadventure experiexperi

ence.ence. MoreMore specifically,specifically, thethe purposepurpose ofof thisthis rere

searchsearch waswas toto useuse thethe means-endmeans-end approachapproach toto

developdevelop aa betterbetter understandingunderstanding ofof thethe outcomesoutcomes

obtainedobtained fromfrom completingcompleting anan OutwardOutward BoundBound

course.course. Specifically,Specifically, thethe studystudy examinedexamined thethe

linkageslinkages betweenbetween thethe attributesattributes ofof thethe serser

vice/programvice/program experiencedexperienced (in(in thisthis case,case, thethe eleele

mentsments ofof anan OutwardOutward BoundBound course)course) andand thethe

benefitsbenefits andand higher-levelhigher-level outcomesoutcomes andand personalpersonal

valuesvalues obtainedobtained oror reinforcedreinforced byby completingcompleting thethe

course.course.

LITERATURELITERATURE REVIEWREVIEW

BeforeBefore continuing,continuing, itit isis usefuluseful toto understandunderstand howhow

thisthis researchresearch contributescontributes toto thethe broaderbroader outdooroutdoor

adventureadventure educationeducation literature.literature.

OutdoorOutdoor AdventureAdventure EducationEducation ProgramsPrograms

OutdoorOutdoor adventureadventure educationeducation programsprograms areare aa

fonnfonn ofof experientialexperiential education.education. ExperientialExperiential

educationeducation isis "learning"learning byby doing."doing." JohnJohn DeweyDewey

waswas oneone ofof thethe firstfirst educatorseducators whowho wrotewrote aboutabout

andand practicedpracticed experientialexperiential learning.learning. "Dewey's"Dewey's

learninglearning sequencesequence includedincluded bothboth theorytheory andand exex

perience"perience" (Wurdinger(Wurdinger && Priest,Priest, 1999,1999, p.p. 187).187).

CharacteristicsCharacteristics ofof experientialexperiential educationeducation thatthat

havehave beenbeen associatedassociated withwith effectiveeffective studentstudent

learninglearning includeinclude thatthat experienceexperience isis thethe bestbest

teacher,teacher, humanshumans dodo learnlearn byby doing,doing, usingusing allall

sensessenses toto learnlearn isis effective,effective, knowledgeknowledge shouldshould bebe

acquiredacquired throughthrough experience,experience, andand "the"the whatwhat andand

thethe howhow areare inseparableinseparable counterpartscounterparts forfor goodgood

teaching"teaching" (Freeberg(Freeberg && Taylor,Taylor, 1963,1963, p.p. 3).3). ExEx

perientialperiential educationeducation cancan occuroccur inin variousvarious setset

tings,tings, suchsuch asas ropesropes courses,courses, climbingclimbing walls,walls, serser

vicevice learning,learning, internships,internships, classroomclassroom instruction,instruction,

andand wildernesswilderness adventures.adventures.

WildernessWilderness tripstrips occuroccur inin thethe wildernesswilderness setset

ting,ting, aa settingsetting thatthat humanshumans dodo notnot control.control. AA

wildernesswilderness areaarea isis aa physicalphysical andand conceptualconceptual

place,place, whichwhich isis "relative"relative ratherrather thanthan anan absoluteabsolute

conceptionconception andand condition"condition" (Miles,(Miles, 1999,1999, p.p. 321).321).

TheThe wildernesswilderness providesprovides anan environmentenvironment forfor

challenge,challenge, growth,growth, andand developmentdevelopment ofof bothboth inin

dividualsdividuals andand groups.groups. TheThe wildernesswilderness isis usedused byby

millionsmillions ofof peoplepeople everyevery yearyear forfor individualindividual

growthgrowth andand challenge,challenge, groupgroup dynamics,dynamics, andand

therapeutictherapeutic intentionsintentions (Ewert(Ewert && McAvoy,McAvoy, 2000).2000).

AccordingAccording toto FrieseFriese (1996)(1996) overover 700700 organizaorganiza

tionstions offeroffer wildernesswilderness programsprograms forfor personalpersonal

growth,growth, andand accordingaccording toto GagerGager (1996),(1996), thesethese

programsprograms areare increasingincreasing inin numbersnumbers byby aboutabout 1515

percentpercent perper year.year.

CommonCommon featuresfeatures ofof outdooroutdoor adventureadventure eduedu

cationcation programsprograms includeinclude thethe settingsetting inin whichwhich

theythey occur,occur, whichwhich isis usuallyusually thethe outdoorsoutdoors oror aa

wildernesswilderness setting.setting. TheyThey usuallyusually involveinvolve smallsmall

groups,groups, rangingranging inin sizessizes upup toto 1616 people.people. TheyThey

usuallyusually requirerequire masterymastery ofof skillsskills toto meetmeet physicalphysical

and/orand/or mentalmental challenges·challenges· thatthat thethe individualindividual oror

groupgroup maymay face.face. TheseThese challengeschallenges involveinvolve

groupgroup problemproblem solvingsolving andand decision-makingdecision-making

skills.skills. UsuallyUsually withwith outdooroutdoor educationeducation propro

grams,grams, thethe leadershipleadership actsacts moremore asas aa facilitatorfacilitator oror

instructorinstructor andand notnot asas aa guideguide oror aa leader.leader. ProPro

gramsgrams cancan requirerequire aa varietyvariety ofof physicalphysical activitiesactivities

andand challengeschallenges (Hattie,(Hattie, Marsh,Marsh, Neill,Neill, && RichRich

~rds,~rds, 1997),1997), suchsuch asas backpackingbackpacking oror rockrock climbclimb

mg.mg.

USINGUSING MEANS-ENDMEANS-END THEORYTHEORY TOTO UNDERSTANDUNDERSTAND THETHE OUTDOOROUTDOOR ADVNETUREADVNETURE EXPERIENCEEXPERIENCE

dering"dering" (Reynolds(Reynolds && Gutman,Gutman, 1988).1988). Similarly,Similarly,

thethe seriesseries ofof responsesresponses linkinglinking aa particularparticular outout

comecome toto aa personalpersonal valuevalue isis referredreferred toto asas aa ladlad

der.der. AnAn exampleexample fromfrom thisthis datadata ofof aa ladderladder inin

cludescludes thethe attributeattribute ofof "the"the completioncompletion ofof thethe

course"course" (course(course completion),completion), followedfollowed byby thethe

consequenceconsequence ofof "1"1 hadhad doubtsdoubts aboutabout whetherwhether II

couldcould completecomplete thethe coursecourse well"well" (personal(personal chalchal

lenges),lenges), whichwhich linkedlinked toto thethe valuevalue ofof "complet"complet

inging itit mademade meme feelfeel 11 accomplishedaccomplished something"something"

(a(a sensesense ofof accomplishment).accomplishment).

DATADATA ANALYSISANALYSIS

TheThe datadata obtainedobtained fromfrom eacheach respondentrespondent waswas

editededited andand enteredentered intointo aa computercomputer programprogram

calledcalled LadderMapLadderMap (Gengler(Gengler && Reynolds,Reynolds, 1995).1995).

AsAs thethe conceptsconcepts werewere enteredentered intointo thethe program,program,

contentcontent codescodes werewere formedformed basedbased onon phrasesphrases oror

keykey wordswords thatthat emerged.emerged. TheseThese contentcontent codescodes

werewere codedcoded byby twotwo researchers,researchers, reviewedreviewed byby anan

independentindependent coder,coder, andand thenthen reviewedreviewed byby twotwo

facultyfaculty members.members. AA seriesseries ofof hierarchicalhierarchical valuevalue

mapsmaps (HVMs),(HVMs), whichwhich providedprovided aa graphicalgraphical sumsum

marymary ofof thethe relationshipsrelationships andand linkslinks betweenbetween thethe

attributes,attributes, consequences,consequences, andand valuesvalues werewere thenthen

constructed.constructed. EachEach HVMHVM summarizedsummarized thethe keykey

linkageslinkages amongamong thethe outcomesoutcomes andand personalpersonal

valuesvalues thatthat emergedemerged fromfrom contentcontent analysisanalysis propro

cedures.cedures. WhileWhile creatingcreating thethe HVMs,HVMs, thethe rere

searchersearcher determineddetermined whichwhich itemsitems andand relationrelation

shipsships shouldshould bebe representedrepresented andand wherewhere thesethese

itemsitems shouldshould bebe placedplaced onon thethe HVMHVM (Golden(Golden

bergberg etet al.,al., 2000)2000) (Figure(Figure 1).1). TheThe sizesize ofof thethe circir

clecle representingrepresenting anan outcomeoutcome reflectedreflected thethe numnum

berber ofof respondentsrespondents whowho mentionedmentioned thethe concept,concept,

whilewhile thethe thicknessthickness ofof thethe lineslines onon thethe HVMHVM

connectingconnecting thethe circlescircles reflectedreflected thethe numbernumber ofof

timestimes thethe outcomesoutcomes werewere linkedlinked together.together. TheThe

largerlarger thethe circlecircle oror thethe thickerthicker thethe line,line, thethe moremore

frequentlyfrequently thethe conceptconcept oror linkagelinkage occurred:occurred:

TheThe relationshiprelationship amongamong thethe conceptsconcepts onon thethe

HVMHVM providedprovided usefuluseful insightinsight intointo thethe outcomesoutcomes

andand higher-levelhigher-level valuesvalues associatedassociated withwith thethe exex

perienceperience ofof participatingparticipating inin anan OutwardOutward BoundBound

course.course. TheThe concreteconcrete outcomesoutcomes atat thethe bottombottom ofof

thethe mapmap areare thethe keykey aspectsaspects thatthat helphelp createcreate thethe

higherhigher valuevalue outcomesoutcomes shownshown atat thethe toptop ofof thethe

map.map.

RESULTSRESULTS ANDAND ANALYSISANALYSIS

OfOf thethe 294294 questionnairesquestionnaires thatthat werewere disdis

tributedtributed toto coursecourse participants,participants, aa totaltotal ofof 216216

werewere returned,returned, representingrepresenting aa 73.5%73.5% returnreturn rate.rate.

StudyStudy participantsparticipants rangedranged inin ageage fromfrom 14-6614-

yearsyears old,old, withwith mostmost (83.3%)(83.3%) betweenbetween 1414 toto 1818

yearsyears old.old. ParticipantsParticipants completedcompleted coursescourses rangrang

inging inin lengthlength fromfrom 44 toto 2121 days,days, withwith halfhalf (50%)(50%)

lastinglasting 2121 days.days. TheThe majoritymajority ofof respondentsrespondents

werewere malemale (57.4%),(57.4%), whitewhite (84.3%),(84.3%), andand alsoalso stustu

dentsdents (90.3%).(90.3%). Twenty-threeTwenty-three percentpercent receivedreceived aa

scholarshipscholarship toto attendattend OutwardOutward Bound.Bound. AA largelarge

majoritymajority ofof participantsparticipants (92.6%)(92.6%) wouldwould recomrecom

mendmend anan OutwardOutward BoundBound coursecourse toto aa friend.friend.

ContentContent categories,categories, oror themes,.themes,. werewere genergener

atedated fromfrom thethe data.data. TheThe listlist ofof attributesattributes yieldedyielded

1515 categoriescategories rangingranging fromfrom thethe entireentire coursecourse toto

specificspecific coursecourse components,components, suchsuch asas solosolo oror rockrock

climbing.climbing. FourteenFourteen differentdifferent codescodes forfor thethe concon

sequencessequences werewere generated,generated, andand eighteight valuevalue codescodes

werewere created.created. TheThe contentcontent codescodes werewere develdevel

opedoped firstfirst byby twotwo researchersresearchers workingworking together,together,

thenthen byby anan independentindependent codercoder whowho examinedexamined

30%30% ofof thethe data,data, andand finallyfinally byby aa thirdthird andand forthforth

researcherresearcher whowho reviewedreviewed thethe codescodes andand codingcoding

assignments.assignments.

TheThe hierarchicalhierarchical valuevalue mapmap (or(or HVM)HVM) gengen

eratederated forfor thethe entireentire sample,sample, shownshown inin FigureFigure 1,1,

isis basedbased onon aa cutoffcutoff pointpoint ofof ninenine associationsassociations

betweenbetween conceptsconcepts whichwhich representsrepresents 62.162.1 %% ofof thethe

associationsassociations amongamong thethe conceptsconcepts inin respondents'respondents'

laddersladders (for(for aa discussiondiscussion ofof thethe detailsdetails involvedinvolved

inin creatingcreating anan HVMHVM seesee GoldenbergGoldenberg etet aI.,aI.,

TheThe primaryprimary attributesattributes listedlisted byby participantsparticipants

inin theirtheir orderorder ofof responseresponse includedincluded thethe overalloverall

course,course, coursecourse components,components, interactions,interactions, rockrock

climbing,climbing, expeditioning,expeditioning, andand campcraft.campcraft. TheThe

significantsignificant consequencesconsequences includedincluded relationshipsrelationships

withwith others,others, knowledge,knowledge, andand personalpersonal

growth/challenges.growth/challenges. TheThe significantsignificant valuesvalues werewere

transference,transference, self-awareness,self-awareness, self-confidence,self-confidence,

andand personalpersonal goals/values.goals/values.

GOLDENBERG,GOLDENBERG, MCAVOY,MCAVOY, KLENOSKY,KLENOSKY, && HOLMANHOLMAN

VALUEVALUE

oo

ConsequenceConsequence

FF

AClllEVEMENTAClllEVEMENT OFOF AA ~~ ~~ attributeattribute

PERSONALPERSONAL GOALSNALUEGOALSNALUE FUNFUN ANDAND ENJOENJO TT OFOF LIFELIFE ASENSEOFACCOMPLSHMENTASENSEOFACCOMPLSHMENT

n=57n= n=64n=

SELF-AWARENESS/SELF-AWARENESS/

IMPROVEMENT/FULFILLMENTIMPROVEMENT/FULFILLMENT

WARMWARM RELATIONSHIPSRELATIONSHIPS WIlliWIlli OTIlERSOTIlERS

n=I07n=I n=30n=

II

leadershipleadership

opportunitiesopportunities

\e\e

JJ

coursecourse overalloverall

lFI02lFI

FigureFigure 1.1. HierarchicalHierarchical ValueValue MapMap forfor OutwardOutward BoundBound ParticipantsParticipants (n=216).(n=216).

GOLDENBERG,GOLDENBERG, MCAVOY,MCAVOY, KLENOSKY,KLENOSKY, && HOLMANHOLMAN

searchsearch couldcould bebe conductedconducted toto exploreexplore thethe issueissue

..ofof whetherwhether "transference,""transference," oneone ofof thethe moremore inin

terestingteresting findingsfindings ofof thethe presentpresent study,study, diddid occur.occur.

REFERENCESREFERENCES

Botschen,Botschen, G.G. && Hemetsberger,Hemetsberger, A.A. (1998).(1998).

DiagnosingDiagnosing means-endmeans-end structuresstructures toto

determinedetermine thethe degreedegree ofof potentialpotential marketingmarketing

programprogram standardization.standardization. JournalJournal ofof

BusinessBusiness Research,Research, 42,42, 151-159.151-159.

Ewert,Ewert, A.A. (1987).(1987). ResearchResearch inin experientialexperiential eduedu

cation:cation: AnAn overview.overview. JournalforJournalfor ExperienExperien

tialtial Education,Education, 10,10, 4-7.4-7.

Ewert,Ewert, A.A. && McAvoy,McAvoy, L.L. (2000).(2000). TheThe effectseffects

ofof wildernesswilderness settingssettings onon organizedorganized groups:groups:

AA state-of-knowledgestate-of-knowledge paper.paper. InIn McCool,McCool, S.,S.,

Cole,Cole, D.,D., Borrie,Borrie, W.,W., andand O'Loughlin,O'Loughlin, J.J.

(Eds.),(Eds.), WildernessWilderness ScienceScience inin aa TimeTime ofof

ChangeChange Conference.Conference. Vol.Vol. 3:3: WildernessWilderness asas

aa PlacePlace forfor ScientificScientific Inquiry.Inquiry. (pp.(pp. 13-26).13-26).

USDAUSDA ForestForest ServiceService Proceedings.Proceedings.

Ford,Ford, P.P. (1981).(1981). PrinciplesPrinciples andand practicespractices inin

outdooroutdoor andand environmentalenvironmental education.education. NewNew

York:York: WileyWiley PublishingPublishing Company.Company.

Frauman,Frauman, E.E. && Cunningham,Cunningham, P.P. H.H. (2001).(2001). UsUs

inging means-endmeans-end approachapproach toto understandunderstand thethe

factorsfactors thatthat influenceinfluence greenwaygreenway use.use. JourJour

nalnal ofofParkPark andand RecreationRecreation Administration,Administration,

Freeberg,Freeberg, W.W. && Taylor,Taylor, L.L. (1963).(1963). ProgramsPrograms inin

outdooroutdoor education.education. Minneapolis,Minneapolis, MN:MN: BurBur

gessgess PublishingPublishing Company.Company.

Friese,Friese, G.G. (1996).(1996). AA typologytypology andand surveysurvey ofof

wildernesswilderness experienceexperience programsprograms nationwide.nationwide.

UnpublishedUnpublished master'smaster's thesis,thesis, UniversityUniversity ofof

Idaho.Idaho.

Gager,Gager, D.D. (1996).(1996). AgencyAgency policiespolicies andand wilderwilder

nessness managersmanagers attitudesattitudes towardstowards wildernesswilderness

experienceexperience programs.programs. UnpublishedUnpublished master'smaster's

thesis,thesis, UniversityUniversity ofof Idaho.Idaho.

Gengler,Gengler, C.C. E.E. && Reynolds,Reynolds, T.T. J.J. (1995).(1995). LadLad

derMapderMap [Computer[Computer Software].Software]. Camden,Camden, NJ:NJ:

Means-EndMeans-End Software.Software.

Goldenberg,Goldenberg, M.M. A.A. (1997).(1997). UnderstandingUnderstanding thethe

benefitsbenefits ofofropesropes coursecourse experiencesexperiences usingusing

means-endmeans-end analysis.analysis. UnpublishedUnpublished master'smaster's

thesis,thesis, PurduePurdue University,University, Indiana.Indiana.

Goldenberg,Goldenberg, M.M. A.,A., Klenosky,Klenosky, D.D. B.,B., O'Leary,O'Leary, J.J.

T.,T., && Templin,Templin, T.T. J.J. (2000).(2000). AA means-endmeans-end

investigationinvestigation ofof ropesropes coursecourse experiences.experiences.

JournalJournal ofofLeisureLeisure Research,Research, 32,32, 208-224.208-224.

Gutman,Gutman, J.J. (1982).(1982). AA means-endmeans-end chainchain modelmodel

basedbased onon consumerconsumer categorizationcategorization processes.processes.

JournalJournal ofofMarketing,Marketing, 46,46, 60-72.60-72.

USINGUSING MEANS-ENDMEANS-END THEORYTHEORY TOTO UNDERSTANDUNDERSTAND THETHE OUTDOOROUTDOOR ADVNETUREADVNETURE EXPERIENCEEXPERIENCE

Hattie,Hattie, J.,J., Marsh,Marsh, H.,H., Neill,Neill, J.,J., && Richards,Richards, G.G.

(1997).(1997). AdventureAdventure educationeducation andand OutwardOutward

Bound:Bound: Out-of-classOut-of-class experiencesexperiences thatthat makemake

aa lastinglasting difference.difference. ReviewReview ofofEducationalEducational

Research,Research, 67,67, 43-87.43-87.

Hirsch,Hirsch, 1.1. (1999).(1999). DevelopmentalDevelopmental adventureadventure propro-

grams.grams. InIn J.C.J.C. MilesMiles && S.S. PriestPriest (Eds.),(Eds.), AdAd-

ventureventure Programming.Programming. (pp.(pp. 13-27).13-27). StateState

College,College, PPA:A: VentureVenture Publishing,Publishing, Inc.Inc.

Klenosky,Klenosky, D.D. B.B. (2002).(2002). TheThe "pull""pull" ofof tourismtourism

destinations:destinations: AA means-endmeans-end investigation.investigation.

JournalJournal ofofTravelTravel Research,Research, 40,385-395.40,385-395.

Klenosky,Klenosky, D.,D., Frauman,Frauman, E.,E., Norman,Norman, W.,W., &&

Gengler,Gengler, C.C. (1998).(1998). Nature-basedNature-based tourists'tourists'

useuse ofof interpretiveinterpretive services:services: AA means-endmeans-end

investigation.investigation. TheThe JournalJournal ofofTourismTourism StudStud-

ies,ies, 9,9, 26-36.26-36.

Klenosky,Klenosky, D.,D., Gengler,Gengler, C.,C., && Mulvey,Mulvey, M.M.

(1993).(1993). UnderstandingUnderstanding thethe factorsfactors influencinfluenc-

inging skiski destinationdestination choice:choice: AA means-endmeans-end

analyticanalytic approach.approach. JournalJournal ofofLeisureLeisure ReRe-

search,search, 25,25, 362-379.362-379.

Miles,Miles, J.C.J.C. (1999).(1999). Wilderness.Wilderness. InIn Miles,Miles, J.C.J.C. &&

Priest,Priest, S.S. (Eds.),(Eds.), AdventureAdventure Programming.Programming.

(pp.321-3230.(pp.321-3230. StateState College,College, PA:PA: VentureVenture

Publishing,Publishing, Inc.Inc.

Pieters,Pieters, R.,R., Botschen,Botschen, G.,G., && Thelen,Thelen, E.E. (1998).(1998).

CustomerCustomer desiredesire expectationsexpectations aboutabout serviceservice

employees:employees: AnAn analysisanalysis ofof hierarchicalhierarchical relarela-

tions.tions. PsychologyPsychology && Marketing,Marketing, 15,15, 755 755-

Priest,Priest, S.S. && Gass,Gass, M.M. (1997).(1997). EffectiveEffective leaderleader-

shipship inin adventureadventure programming.programming. ChamCham-

paign,paign, IL:IL: HumanHuman Kinetics.Kinetics.

Reynolds,Reynolds, T.T. J.J. && Gutman,Gutman, J.J. (1988).(1988). LadderLadder-

inging theory,theory, method,method, analysis,analysis, andand interpretainterpreta-

tion.tion. JournalJournal ofofAdvertisingAdvertising Research,Research,

Walker,Walker, B.B. A.A. && Olson,Olson, J.J. C.C. (1991).(1991). MeansMeans-

endend chains:chains: ConnectingConnecting productsproducts withwith self.self.

JournalJournal ofofBusinessBusiness Research,Research, 22,22, 111-118.111-118.

Wurdinger,Wurdinger, S.S. && Priest,Priest, S.S. (1999).(1999). IntegratingIntegrating

theorytheory andand applicationapplication inin experientialleamexperientialleam-

ing.ing. InIn J.C.J.C. MilesMiles && S.S. PriestPriest (Eds.),Adven(Eds.),Adven-

tureture Programming.Programming. (pp.(pp. 187-192).187-192). State·State·

College,College, PPA:A: VentureVenture Publishing,Publishing, Inc.Inc.